The theory of scholars in the mainland of China that is religion led to the long-lasting controversies over whether or not confucianism is religion.A macroexamination and objective evaluation of the theory and line of reasoning become necessary.Firstly,Confucianists of mainland are influenced by Western scholars in studying confucianism and compare Confucianism to Western religions.Secondly,greatly and dogmatically influenced by Marxism,Confucianists of the mainland do acdemic researches under the guidance of dual antagonistic thinking which misleads researches on Confucianism;Thirdly,influenced by Western substantism,mainland scholars study confucianism unilaterally,abstractly and absolutely.