荟萃分析
同行反馈
对比度(视觉)
心理学
数学教育
计算机科学
医学
内科学
人工智能
作者
Sina Scherer,Steve Graham,Vera Busse
标识
DOI:10.1016/j.learninstruc.2024.101961
摘要
Feedback is important for writing improvement, but research suggests that not all learners benefit equally from feedback. This meta-analysis examined if different feedback treatments given by different feedback agents are differentially effective for first (L1), second (L2), and foreign language (FL) learners at secondary schools and universities. Our meta-analysis included studies with an experimental or quasi-experimental design. We computed effect sizes for surface- and deep-level writing outcomes. Across 200 comparisons, surface-level feedback significantly improved surface-level outcomes (g = 0.58), with higher effects for FL (g = 0.69) than for L2 learners (g = 0.34). However, such feedback may have detrimental effects on FL deep-level outcomes (g = −0.23). In contrast, deep-level feedback demonstrated positive effects on deep-level outcomes (g = 0.80), with larger effects for L1 (g = 1.26) than for FL learners (g = 0.37; non-significant). Combined surface-and deep-level feedback positively affected both deep-level (g = 0.54) and surface-level outcomes (g = 0.36) for all learners. Instructor feedback demonstrated overall moderate benefits for both outcomes showing greater impact on FL learners (g = 0.72) than on L2 learners (g = 0.35) for surface-level outcomes. Peer feedback showed medium to large effects for deep-level outcomes (FL learners: g = 0.76; L1 learners: g = 1.46). In contrast, algorithm-based feedback showed a non-significant medium effect on FL learners' surface-level outcomes (g = 0.53), and self-feedback showed a non-significant medium effect on FL learners’ deep-level outcomes (g = 0.55). Lastly, feedback proved effective for both university and secondary school students, thereby underscoring its crucial role in fostering writing.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI