摘要
The concept of critical thinking we propound highlights stages in the development of critical thinking. Everyone of us, viewed as a thinking being, is somewhere in the range of unreflective to master thinker. To advance beyond beginning thinker one must come to terms with the fact that there is a body of interrelated knowledge about the mind and skills potential for the mind that must be internalized at progressive levels of depth and skill, and that one must monitor one's movement through these levels of excellence via planned practice. We believe that learning to think critically is analogous to learning to play the piano. Thinking critically at an advanced level without disciplined practice is as unnatural to the human mind as sitting down at a piano and spontaneously playing Chopin's Polonaise. In this column we continue to elaborate one of the most powerful ideas for the improvement of thinking-seeking the logic of thingswhich, in turn, we believe can only be mastered through planned practice. Unfortunately, very few students see the main goal of their learning as figuring out the logic of what they are studying, and few teachers. are teaching for this essential end: the logic of biology, the logic of chemistry, the logic of economics, the logic of writing and so forth. What is often learned, then, is a counterfeit of the logic of the discipline (fragmented parts of it) or many of the parts but in such a way that the student may get a high grade by cramming large masses of only partially digested contents of a textbook or set of lectures. The thinking that drives the discipline is never, by this process, understood. In this column we discuss how to design instruction to emphasize teaching students to seek, and think within, the logic of what they are studying. For brevity's sake, we will not elaborate on all of the important details of the mode of instruction we are advocating, but will aim for an entry-level understanding of such instruction by using the format of a step-by-step procedure. Interested instructors will doubtless have to experiment with the model we are presenting and make contextual adjustments. We will use instruction in history as our main example. A parallel example could be developed in all disciplines. Step One Focus on the name of the content you teach and devise a helpful way to characterize the thinking that is essential to the content. For example, if I teach history my key goal should be to help students learn how to think historically (in an insightful and effective manner). Or, if I teach writing my key goal should be to help students to think like a skilled writer. Or, if I teach sociology, psychology, geography, biology, philosophy, or chemistry then I should be attempting to foster in students the ability to think sociologically, psychologically, geographically, biologically, philosophically, or chemically. As a result, on the first day of class we announce that there is only one goal in the class, which we will be working on every class day, and that is practicing thinking sociologically, psychologically... or whatever applies. Step Two Now inform the students that there is a logic to the subject and that it underlies and creates the thinking we will be practicing. Explain that the best way in which we can begin to appreciate the logic of our subject is through answering eight key questions about the subject: 1. What are the most fundamental purposes, goals, or agendas of thinking within the discipline? 2. What kinds of questions must be asked, or what kinds of problems are solved, when thinking within the discipline3. What sorts of information or data must be collected or analyzed to solve problems within the discipline? 4. What kinds of judgments or evaluations are made by those who interpret and give meaning to data within the discipline? 5. What key assumptions underlie the thinking within the discipline and its agenda? …