Microbreaks are short, informal breaks taken in the workplace that enhance employees’ job well-being, and performance. However, in practice, managers contend that microbreaks during work slows down progress and negatively impacts productivity. Based on information processing theory, we elucidate these inconsistent findings: leader’s perception of employee job control and procrastination at work can explain why employees’ microbreaks may either enhance or undermine leader’s cognition-based trust, with employees’ job performance playing a moderating role in this process. We collected 279 paired questionnaires from leaders and employees. The results indicate that employees’ microbreaks are a double-edged sword. On one hand, for high-performce employees, microbreaks positively influence leader’s cognition-based trust through perception of employee job control. On the other hand, for low-performce employees, microbreaks negatively influence leader’s cognition-based trust through perception of employee procrastination. We provide a more comprehensive theoretical perspective on the dual effects of microbreaks, offering significant theoretical and managerial implications.