Effects of fertilization applications on soil aggregate organic carbon content and assessment of their influencing factors: A meta-analysis

Fertilizer application plays an important role in agricultural soil organic carbon (SOC) and its sustainable management. However, there is a lack of consensus about the mechanisms regarding fertilizer application in the soil on the procedure of carbon sequestration and sink enhancement in the aggregates. In this study, the extent by which various fertilization treatments, fertilization durations, climate conditions, soil texture, and land-use types affected the organic carbon (OC) content of different particle-size aggregates was quantitatively assessed using a meta-analysis of 696 treatment comparisons from 36 published studies. Based on the meta-analysis results, fertilization enhanced the OC contents of macroaggregates and clay and silt particles, particularly through replenishing organic material. Long-term fertilization increased the OC content of macroaggregates (>0.25 mm), while the OC content of the clay and silt particles (<0.053 mm) reached a maximum at 15.4 years of fertilization, after which it reached carbon saturation. Organic fertilizer effectively increased the OC content of small macroaggregates (0.25–2 mm) and microaggregates (0.053–0.25 mm) at lower temperatures and precipitation. Compared with inorganic fertilization, combined organic–inorganic fertilization increased OC contents of all sizes of aggregates in sandy or clay loam soils, but decreased OC contents of microaggregates and clay and silt particles in silt loam soils. All fertilization treatments increased the OC content of all particle-size aggregates in upland soils. In contrast, inorganic fertilization and mixed organic–inorganic fertilization reduced the OC content of microaggregates (0.053–0.25 mm) and clay and silt particles (<0.053 mm) in paddy field soils. In conclusion, the application of organic fertilizers is more conducive to the accumulation of OC in agricultural soil aggregates. Whereas the limiting factors for the accumulation of OC content in soil aggregates vary under different conditions, organic fertilizer inputs should be given more consideration, especially in dryland and coarse-textured soils.