Building on boundary management theory and the qualitative findings of Kreiner, Hellensbe, and Sheep (2009) we develop and test a measure of four boundary management tactics (temporal, physical, behavioral, communicative) for both the work and family domains. We extend the understanding of how people use tactics to manage boundaries by positioning the tactics as mediators allowing us also to explore both antecedents and consequences of these tactics. With respect to antecedents, we explored the impact preference for segmentation had on the engagement of these tactics. On the consequences side, we considered the role of satisfaction and engagement in both the work and family domains. Using a sample of 639 working individuals, we found family segmentation preference lead to greater use of each of the work boundary management tactics while work segmentation preference lead to greater use of all of the family boundary management tactics except behavioral. Turning to the consequences, the work boundary management tactic of physical predicted both job satisfaction and job engagement. The work boundary management tactic of communication predicted job satisfaction while the work boundary management tactic of time predicted job engagement. All four of the family boundary management tactics predicted family satisfaction and all but the family boundary management tactic of communication predicted family engagement. Finally, nine of the sixteen mediated paths were significant. We discuss the study’s implications for theory, research, and practice while suggesting new research directions.