The spread of technologies based on artificial intelligence (AI) has revolutionized the pedagogical field in all institutions of higher learning around the world. This paper focuses on the effects of the introduction of AI tools in the academic performance of students pursuing undergraduate and postgraduate courses. Based on quantitative research design, 320 students (3 universities in India) were sampled using a stratified random sample. AI tool usage frequency, self-efficacy, learning motivation, digital literacy, student engagement, and academic achievement (GPA) were measured using validated instruments. Data analysis was done using multiple linear regression, Pearson correlation analysis, and one-way ANOVA. The findings showed that the AI tool utilization and academic success are positively correlated. was statistically significant ( = 0.42, p < .001). This relationship was verified by mediation analysis which revealed that self-efficacy and motivation mediated this relationship, but the effect was moderated by digital literacy. The average GPA of AI users was 3.57 as compared to non-users which was 2.61. This study concludes that there is a significant opportunity to increase the academic performance at the higher education level with the strategic, scaffolded integration of AI tools, and it implies that the educators, curriculum designers, and policymakers need to pay attention to this opportunity.