摘要
Background Melanocytic nevi are among the most frequently treated lesions in aesthetic dermatology. Various techniques are used for cosmetic or diagnostic purposes. However, comparative evidence regarding treatment efficacy, recurrence risk, cosmetic outcomes, and safety remains inconsistent. Objective To systematically evaluate and compare clinical clearance, recurrence rates, cosmetic outcomes, and adverse events associated with aesthetic techniques used for the removal of melanocytic nevi. Methods A systematic search of PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, ScienceDirect, Wiley, and Google Scholar was conducted for studies published between January 2000 and May 2025. Studies reporting outcomes of surgical or aesthetic interventions for benign melanocytic nevi were included. Data extraction followed PRISMA 2020 guidelines. A random-effects meta-analysis was performed to pool estimates of clinical clearance, recurrence, and cosmetic satisfaction. Subgroup analyses were conducted according to nevus subtype (junctional vs. intradermal) and treatment modality. Risk of bias was assessed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias 2 tool for randomized trials and the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale for observational studies. Results A total of 46 studies involving 4,201 lesions were included. Surgical excision demonstrated the highest clinical clearance rate (96.4%; 95% CI 92.1–99.2) and the lowest recurrence rate (2.1%). Laser-based treatments produced the most favorable cosmetic outcomes, with Er:YAG laser achieving the highest satisfaction score (8.8/10), followed by CO 2 laser (8.4/10), shave excision (7.6/10), and surgical excision (6.2/10). Non-surgical techniques showed higher recurrence rates, including CO 2 laser (12.9%), Er:YAG laser (14.3%), electrosurgery (16.1%), and dermabrasion (22.7%). Subgroup analyses revealed significantly higher recurrence in intradermal nevi compared with junctional nevi (RR = 1.82; 95% CI 1.34–2.39). Sensitivity analyses confirmed the robustness of the results, and no significant publication bias was detected. Conclusion Surgical excision remains the most reliable method for complete melanocytic nevus removal and histopathologic assessment but may yield less favorable cosmetic outcomes. Laser-based treatments, particularly Er:YAG and CO 2 lasers, provide better aesthetic results with acceptable safety but show higher recurrence rates, especially in intradermal nevi. Treatment choice should consider lesion depth, cosmetic priorities, and patient preferences.