Disentangling molecular fluorescence from intrinsic nanoparticle emission is essential to establish reliable structure–property relationships in carbon dots (CDs). The origin of photoluminescence in CDs synthesized from citric acid and urea under solvent‐free conditions (180 °C) is investigated employing two precursor molar ratios (1:1 and 1:10, CA:urea). Prior to rigorous purification, the samples exhibit intense blue or green emission arising from molecular fluorophores formed during the reaction, ascribed to citrazinic acid (CZA) derivatives and to 4‐hydroxy‐1H‐pyrrolo[3,4‐c]pyridine‐1,3,6(2H,5H)‐trione (HPPT). Size‐exclusion chromatography reveals that the equimolar system contains two blue‐emitting CZA‐derived species, one isolated and structurally validated and the other inferred from spectroscopic evidence and likely associated with the CD structure. Conversely, in the urea‐rich system, green‐emitting HPPT is detected alongside minor CZA‐derived species. Optical and nuclear magnetic resonance fingerprints are corroborated by quantum‐chemical calculations. Prolonged dialysis removes diffusible molecular species while indicating that a minor fraction of fluorophores remains associated with the carbon nanostructure. After purification, both samples converge to remarkably similar spectroscopic signatures characterized by multicolor, excitation‐dependent emission and reduced quantum yields, irrespective of precursor stoichiometry. The results demonstrate that genuine CD emission originates predominantly from intrinsic multicolor emissive states of the nanostructures, with only a minor contribution from surface‐associated molecular species.