惯习
社会学
预设
意识形态
认识论
功率(物理)
象征力量
胁迫(语言学)
提升(金属加工)
领域(数学)
机制(生物学)
语言学
社会关系
批评性话语分析
语言意识形态
社交生活
社会理论
社会力量
象征性的
语篇分析
结构和代理
象征性资本
出处
期刊:Journal of humanities, arts and social science
[Hill Publishing Group Inc.]
日期:2026-07-21
卷期号:10 (7): 763-767
标识
DOI:10.26855/jhass.2026.07.003
摘要
This essay compares Bourdieu’s and Fairclough’s accounts of relationships between language, power, and social structure. It argues that both theorists, through concepts such as linguistic capital and symbolic power on the one hand and orders of discourse and ideology on the other, treat language use as socially determined and as a mechanism through which social structures are reproduced, and that both allow for social change through linguistic practice, though only along a broadly top-down path. The essay then compares the two theorists’ differing accounts of power, of how power is exercised—through habitus versus a combination of coercion and consent—and of the methods each adopts for analysis. It closes by raising two concerns: whether Bourdieu’s concept of habitus can adequately account for cases of social mobility, and whether Fairclough’s CDA, given its lack of unified theoretical and methodological standards, risks allowing its critical presuppositions to shape its findings.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI