Design of Dilute Palladium–Indium Alloy Catalysts for the Selective Hydrogenation of CO2 to Methanol

Adding small amounts of a more reactive dopant metal to a more selective host metal is a well-known strategy for promoting the catalytic reactivity of the latter without sacrificing its selectivity. While substantial attention has been given to coinage metal hosts for activating individual C–H or O–H bonds, less attention has been given to more exotic metals, such as indium, which is highly selective in the complex hydrogenation of CO2 to methanol. Herein, we describe the synthesis and properties of Pd–In alloys containing Pd in various states of aggregation (isolated atom, small clusters, and extended clusters) assessed through various characterization methods. These materials exhibit unique catalytic behaviors, with Pd promoting both the reaction rate and methanol selectivity in all cases, though its efficacy is highest when Pd is present in small clusters. The inefficiency of high Pd loadings is due in part to losses in Pd accessibility, while the importance of aggregated vs isolated Pd is theorized to result from accelerated H2 activation. Methods used to synthesize more conventional dilute-limit and single-atom alloy catalysts can, therefore, be extended to non-coinage metal hosts to promote and control more complex chemistries, though the roles of ensemble size may greatly differ.