Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy Reveals That Model Silicon Anodes Demonstrate Global Solid Electrolyte Interphase Passivation Degradation during Calendar Aging

Silicon is a promising next-generation anode to increase energy density over commercial graphite anodes, but calendar life remains problematic. In this work, scanning electrochemical microscopy was used to track the site-specific reactivity of a silicon thin film surface over time to determine if undesirable Faradaic reactions were occurring at the formed solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) during calendar aging in four case scenarios: formation between 1.5 V and 100 mV with subsequent rest starting at (1) 1.5 V and (2) 100 mV and formation between 0.75 V and 100 mV with subsequent rest starting at (3) 0.75 V and (4) 100 mV. In all cases, the electrical passivation of silicon decreased with increasing time and potential relative to Li/Li+ over a 3 day period. Along with the decrease in passivation, the homogeneity of passivation over a 500 μm2 area decreased with time. Despite some local "hot spots" of reactivity, the areal uniformity of passivation suggests global SEI failure (e.g., SEI dissolution) rather than localized (e.g., cracking) failure. The silicon delithiated to 1.5 V vs Li/Li+ was less passivated than the lithiated silicon (at the beginning of rest, the forward rate constants, kf, for ferrocene redox were 7.19 × 10-5 and 3.17 × 10-7 m/s, respectively) and was also found to be more reactive than the pristine silicon surface (kf of 5 × 10-5 m/s). This reactivity was likely the result of SEI oxidation. When the cell was only delithiated up to 0.75 V versus Li/Li+, the surface was still passivating (kf of 6.11 × 10-6 m/s), but still less so than the lithiated surface (kf of 3.03 × 10-9 m/s). This indicates that the potential of the anode should be kept at or below ∼0.75 V vs Li/Li+ to prevent decreasing SEI passivation. This information will help with tuning the voltage windows for prelithiation in Si half cells and the operating voltage of Si full cells to optimize calendar life. The results provided should encourage the research community to investigate chemical, rather than mechanical, modes of failure during calendar aging and to stop using the typical convention of 1.5 V as a cutoff potential for cycling Si in half cells.