Social conformity occurs when individuals forego their personal judgements to agree with opposing judgements of a group majority. While conformity was initially observed and investigated in physical groups, recently there has been an increasing interest to understand dynamics of this phenomenon in online group settings. This survey summarises 36 years of social conformity literature (1988–2023) and reviews its occurrences, positive and negative outcomes, and contextual and personal determinants in online groups. By doing so, we identify gaps in the conformity literature that require further investigation, discuss common challenges and inform the design of future online conformity studies.