Public engagement is essential for governance effectiveness. Although its dynamics have been reshaped by the rapid advancement of digital technologies, little is known about how digital government influences public engagement. Grounded in the expectancy-disconfirmation model, this study investigates the effect of digital government on public engagement—a dual-dimensional construct comprising behavioral participation and affective satisfaction—and examines the moderating role of government responsiveness, operationalized as response speed and length. Using a panel of 4,381 city-year observations from 337 Chinese cities (2011 to 2023) and a staggered difference-in-differences approach, we find that digital government has a dual effect on public engagement: it promotes citizens’ participation in governance while reducing their satisfaction. However, faster and more detailed responses can counteract the decline in satisfaction, even though extremely detailed replies may slightly dampen participation. These findings provide valuable theoretical and practical implications for understanding and managing digital-era public engagement.