摘要
Dr. Colen: The first patient is a 29-year-old woman who underwent a periareolar subpectoral augmentation with a round, smooth saline implant 1 year ago ( Figure 1 ). Dr. Giese, can you describe this patient's problem and how it might have been avoided? Dr. Giese: In this oblique view, it appears that the patient has a double-bubble deformity. In addition, her breast mound and the implant appear unequal; her left breast seems higher on the chest wall than the right. This 29-year-old woman underwent periareolar subpectoral augmentation with a round, smooth saline implant 1 year ago. She does not like the appearance of her breasts. To avoid the occurrence of a double bubble, I would not have chosen to obliterate the natural inframammary fold, if possible. The natural inframammary fold acts as a very strong sling to keep the implants properly positioned on the chest wall. Here, the implant has fallen beyond the natural portion of her breast and into the surgically created inframammary fold pocket. This patient needed an augmentation mastopexy. I like the periareolar approach and the subpectoral position with a round, smooth saline implant, but, again, I would have tried to avoid lowering or changing her natural inframammary folds. Maybe that would have meant using a smaller implant. I do not know what necessitated lowering the folds. Dr. Colen: Dr. Hammond, what would your initial approach to this patient have been? Dr. Hammond: If I felt that she needed a mastopexy, I would have performed a periareolar mastopexy without hesitation. When I am already in the periareolar incision, I use that to gain access to the breast; it is a very nice approach to the lower breast apron. The inframammary-fold incision sometimes masks the location of that fold when the implant is inserted. But from above, through the periareolar incision, you can really see that lower apron quite nicely. Lowering a fold is a maneuver that should be approached with tremendous care and performed only when absolutely indicated. You can see where the original fold was, and the distance from that point up to the areola and the nipple is certainly adequate to accommodate an augmentation of this size. If the folds are inadvertently lowered, of course, this can result in a double-bubble situation. I would perform a capsular manipulation along that fold, incising along the capsule and using the capsule as an apron to hike the fold up superiorly to restore the breast to its original fold location. Revising the fold would reposition the implant in the breast and improve the double-bubble deformity. I agree with Dr. Giese that the left nipple still looks low. She may need a revision of the periareolar lift to raise the nipple. Dr. Colen: Dr. Graf, how would you correct this problem if the patient was unhappy with this double bubble and wanted her contour restored? Dr. Graf: If the implant was vertically positioned and problem-free, I would keep it intact. There is excess skin in the inframammary region that can be diminished or eliminated with the vertical technique, in which skin is moved inferiorly. This technique would enable me to correct the asymmetry of the nipple-areolar complex, elevating the left side. Dr. Colen: Are you saying that a vertical incision would improve her lower breast contour? Dr. Graf: Yes. Through the vertical incision, I can perform an internal fixation of the previous inframammary fold, correcting the double-bubble deformity. Dr. Colen: Dr. Hammond, do you think a vertical incision would be helpful? Dr. Hammond: I do not think that the vertical approach would be the best approach. It is basically a horizontal problem; adding another vector would not help the double-bubble phenomenon. I believe that Dr. Graf was actually referring to the ptosis of the nipple and the areola. Adding a vertical component can help tremendously in shaping the breast and providing a more cone-shaped appearance. But a vertical incision is not going to help that double-bubble deformity along the inframammary folds. Dr. Colen: When you look at her tan line, it appears that the top of her nipple is quite close to the top of her tan line. Would you be concerned about raising her nipple? How would you perform the periareolar mastopexy? Dr. Hammond: It looks as if the left side is slightly lower than the right, so I might perform a unilateral mastopexy. The right side actually looks okay, except for the double-bubble deformity. If I were to use a periareolar approach, I would stabilize the opening through which the mastopexy is performed and then allow the areola to sit in that opening without tension. I would cut the areola at a diameter of 50 to 52 mm — greater than what I ultimately will need. The outer incision is performed superiorly, as far as necessary, to achieve the desired lift. I use a Gore-Tex suture (WL Gore & Associates, Elkton, MD); it is permanent, strong, very slippery, and slides easily through the dermal cuff around that areolar opening. You can control that opening, millimeter by millimeter, as you cinch the knot down. I actually cinch it down to an opening that is less than 52 mm to about 44 mm. With the patient upright, I can convert that opening into a perfect circle by deepithelializing a small additional bit of skin if needed. Then the nipple and areola can be raised and will fit into that opening without tension. That has been a very effective way to create a natural-looking nipple and areola that does not appear plastered against the apex of the breast. Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, do you think anatomically-shaped implants would benefit this patient? Dr. Giese: No. She has adequate breast tissue, and a round implant placed in the subpectoral position produces essentially the same aesthetic result as an anatomically shaped implant. Another reason not to choose an anatomically shaped implant is the possibility that the implant will turn and create additional deformity; it would just add an additional variable without providing a clear benefit. Dr. Colen: Dr. Graf, if this patient wanted silicone-gel implants instead of saline, would there be specific considerations in choosing the size or the shape of the silicone implant to replace a saline implant? Dr. Graf: Silicone gel is often preferred in Brazil because these implants are felt to produce a better breast shape. But in this patient, the size and shape of the saline implants look good. I would not change the implant shape to an anatomic one, because it could worsen the inferior pole fullness that we are trying to correct with the vertical scar. Dr. Colen: But if a patient had a 275-cc saline implant, would you be able to switch to a 275-cc cohesive gel, or would you have to adjust the volume because of the shape of the silicone implant compared with that of the saline one? Dr. Graf: The cohesive gel implant would have to be smaller, maybe 250 cc. Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, do you think that implants that are high or low profile are of any advantage in treating a patient with this degree of ptosis? Dr. Giese: I would decide to use a high- or low-profile implant on the basis of 3 parameters: base width of the breast, position of the breast on the chest wall (high or low), and desired breast size. Dr. Colen: The next patient is a 23-year-old woman who would like to improve her breast contour and attain a larger cup size, going from 34B to 34C ( Figure 2 ). Her right breast is slightly larger than her left. Dr. Giese, what procedure would you recommend, and how would you plan that procedure? This 23-year old woman would like to improve her breast contour and gain one cup size. Dr. Giese: Considering her asymmetry, I might or might not use implants of different sizes. I cannot judge from the photograph how much larger the right breast is. She wants to improve her contour, and she has moderate to severe breast ptosis, with her entire breast tissue volume hanging off the pectoralis major muscles, so she also requires a mastopexy. My preference would be to perform a simultaneous augmentation mastopexy, placing the implant in the subpectoral position. I would offer the option of a silicone gel implant. Her ptosis is so severe that she is going to need at least a vertical incision and possibly a small “T” to reposition the nipple-areola complex. Dr. Colen: Dr. Graf, what would your approach to this patient be? What mastopexy design would you use? Dr. Graf: I would perform a vertical mastopexy. I use the chest wall–based flap, passed under the pectoral muscle loop to maintain the shape over time. This flap will increase the upper pole fullness, creating an enlarging effect, because it seems she has enough tissue to work with. If she wanted an even larger breast, I would use a round, textured cohesive gel implant, maybe 200 cc, in the subfascial plane. That would give the breast shape, and therefore it would be unnecessary to reshape the breast tissue. Dr. Colen: Dr. Hammond, do you have any suggestions? Dr. Hammond: This is a difficult case, and results may be less than satisfactory. Two factors must be appreciated: first, she is tremendously ptotic and asymmetric; second, she has a tuberous breast deformity, particularly on her left breast. The lateral aspect of the breast is rounded and the medial aspect is flat, which is a hallmark of mild constriction of the inframammary fold. Also, the fold is positioned high, although we cannot see it clearly. That combination is very difficult to deal with because the inframammary folds are going to be very problematic. This patient would qualify for one of our silicone gel studies because she does have ptosis. I think that a silicone gel implant is much more forgiving than saline. My preference, because of shape, would be a round, smooth silicone gel implant. As far as implant location, I have some experience with the data Dr. Graf has recently published regarding subfascial implant placement. I have moved, over the past year, into subglandular positioning for most breast augmentations, and I think that elevating the fascia from the superior aspect of the pectoralis major has been a nice adjunct to that technique because it tends to blunt the superior pole and prevent any distortion. A round, smooth silicone gel implant in the subfascial or subglandular position would be my choice. The major problem is the kind of lift to perform. I would start with a periareolar lift, placing the top portion of the areola no more than 2 cm above that fold, and I would purposely try to drop the fold a centimeter or so on each side. That is going to be difficult in a tuberous breast, and I would defer the decision to add a vertical component to the mastopexy until the implants were placed. I would elevate the patient to a sitting position at the end of the procedure, and if a vertical skin excision improved the breast shape, I would execute it. But my feeling is that the periareolar approach alone would probably suffice. With a patient such as this one, I would make sure expectations were realistic. I think there is a significant possibility she will need a revision to achieve the best results, and I would discuss that with her thoroughly before surgery. Dr. Colen: Dr. Graf, do you think that performing reduction or partial tissue resection in a patient such as this one would help? Dr. Graf: The right breast is a little bigger than the left. If the patient wanted to keep her size, I would remove some tissue on the right side. If she wanted a volume increase, I would use an implant. Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, do you think this patient has a significant risk of needing a second procedure? Is recurrence of ptosis likely? Dr. Giese: Absolutely. Dr. Hammond covered several good points, especially advising a patient before surgery, when most of the breast tissue is hanging off the pectoralis muscle, that there is a significant chance she will need a secondary procedure. This patient has 2 strikes against her: she wants to be lifted, and she also wants to be augmented. You are working against the force of gravity; the implant will tend to slip down on the chest wall. I also prefer to use a gel instead of a saline implant for a patient such as this one. I would be cautious about using an implant of more than 300 to 330 cc. Dr. Colen: The next patient is a 31-year-old woman who has had 3 children and would like her breasts lifted. She desires to retain as much breast volume as possible but does not want implants ( Figure 3 ). Dr. Graf, what would be your surgical approach? This 31-year-old woman has had 3 children and would like her breasts lifted. She desires to remain as large as possible and does not want implants. Dr. Graf: She has an extreme breast ptosis and a very low nipple-areolar complex with a lot of skin excess. She has not only a flat upper pole but also a depression right above the nipple-areolar complex bilaterally. I would perform a vertical-scar mastopexy with a horizontal incision associated with the chest wall–based flap, as described by Marchac. 1 I would fix the flap superiorly, passing it under a loop of pectoralis muscle, and remove breast tissue if necessary. This technique can correct ptosis and restore upper pole fullness. I also would decrease her areolar diameter to balance with her new breast. She has a lot of skin excess, so it would be necessary to leave a horizontal scar in the inframammary crease. Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, how would you treat this patient? Dr. Giese: I am a great fan of Dr. Graf's technique of internal glandular rearrangement with the chest wall–based flap. I have some second thoughts, however, when the nipple-areolar complex extends so far down. In this patient, it appears to be at least 30 cm from the sternal notch. I get a much more reliable result using the inferior pedicle and a Wise pattern for skin removal. After 3 children, her poor skin tone (visible on her abdomen and chest) would not respond as well or as easily, in my hands, to the operation Dr. Graf described. Dr. Colen: Dr. Hammond, what are your thoughts about this patient? Dr. Hammond: I would perform a short scar periareolar inferior pedicle reduction (SPAIR) mastopexy in a fairly straightforward fashion. I have performed this operation in numerous patients like this one. Her preoperative appearance demonstrates extreme ptosis. The “rock in the sock” deformity is so evident that she even has divots in her superior pole. She needs not only a breast lift but also an internal shaping and rearrangement of the breast tissue. This surgery should achieve the least possible scarring and the longest-lasting result. That is exactly what the SPAIR The operation is on an inferior the pedicle is from the so that the nipple and areola can be raised as much as is necessary. would be for this The vertical component will be because this patient's breast base diameter needs to be to up the excess and that can be with the SPAIR is not than that associated with the periareolar and vertical The patient's tissue is and into a more anatomic position to shape the breast. This a good result without a in which you must the breast to see it will the shape. this operation and the inframammary fold is not you have a result that will not In a patient such as this one, tissue is already to the there is not going to be much change in skin over time. the areola is and the periareolar approach will decrease nipple size. The end result is that her breasts can be and and and that can be with a periareolar and a vertical scar. Dr. Colen: Dr. Hammond, how would you increase her Dr. Hammond: of the SPAIR operation in a breast The upper pole are quite and then so that superior elevate the complex. You use the patient's for and into position to restore upper pole fullness. This is in aesthetic surgery of we are it to restore and the with the breast, we are using the patient's to and reshape the breast. Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, do you have any to increase her upper pole Dr. Giese: Another breast lift or reduction operation I perform when breasts are so ptotic is the pedicle with skin excision and vertical I would this patient that she might also have a horizontal because I am not that this degree of ptosis can be with a vertical skin I think this is an way to maintain superior fullness. Dr. Colen: Dr. Graf, do you think the operation that you would increase the upper pole Dr. Graf: The breast tissue must be to restore and maintain the upper pole fullness. If you do not use this flap, the of the breast will it to over time. Dr. Giese: I performing Dr. Graf's and I think it superior pole augmentation and to a mastopexy. when the breasts are this I have a more difficult performing it. Dr. Hammond: This is the kind of problem that me very about surgery. It a to and reshape the breast in a way that will a result over time. Dr. Colen: The patient is a woman who has had 2 children and would like to have her breasts and from a small to a ( Figure ). Dr. Graf, how would you help this patient? This woman has had 2 children and would like to have her breasts and augmented. Dr. Graf: This patient has breast and ptosis. I think that to achieve good volume and shape, a breast implant would be I would perform an breast augmentation or an inframammary approach the implant in the subfascial I would elevate the nipple-areolar complex and the diameter of the areola. I would use a suture to avoid areola This approach the of and because it does not through the glandular tissue to get to the implant pocket. If the patient would not a second incision, I would use the periareolar approach, trying to avoid glandular and the implant in the subfascial plane. Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, what would be your approach? Dr. Giese: I would perform an augmentation mastopexy, with a periareolar approach to the implant. I would use a round gel implant in the subpectoral position and then perform the mastopexy. I would raise the patient to a sitting position to see I could perform the mastopexy with a technique and position her nipple with a If I would add the vertical mastopexy I use a and I prefer Dr. Colen: What are your thoughts about implant Dr. Giese: She looks very She is at a high risk for a secondary problem of implant her skin tone and extreme breast ptosis. I would her to choose the implant she could I do not know that I would perform an augmentation if she wanted an implant larger than 300 cc. Dr. Colen: Dr. Hammond, what do you think about this patient? Dr. Hammond: This would be a difficult patient to treat because her degree of deformity is is she has a breast base and she is of these factors can a less than result. I agree with the that the procedure she requires is an augmentation mastopexy. I also would use a round, smooth gel because it is most forgiving as far as shape is who are this do very well with subglandular placement. I prefer not to get with the muscle if I do not have and I have that the degree of in the upper pole really is not the implant is placed subglandular or under the I would use the subglandular approach, using the subfascial technique Dr. Graf has described. In of a superior areolar mastopexy, this patient because a good bit of the skin of her breast apex is up by areola. the areolar diameter is the of the incision will be because of the diameter of the areola. As a the base diameter of the breast will be diminished and the patient may not have a breast size as large as she would It is necessary to balance the base diameter of the implant with the I would use a high profile round, smooth silicone gel It is not going to be a very large because the larger the implant, the greater the placed on the periareolar I would make sure that the patient had a of the degree of augmentation the surgery will Dr. Colen: you think you can elevate her with just the periareolar approach, or do you think you would have to add another Dr. Hammond: I can elevate the as high as is necessary with a periareolar approach. Dr. Colen: Dr. Graf, what are your thoughts on the periareolar approach on this patient? Dr. Graf: I can remove the skin with a periareolar approach in this patient, and I would not use a large implant. I would prefer to anatomic textured cohesive gel implants placed under the I would not use large implants because she has which might recurrence of ptosis. Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, what are your thoughts on the periareolar approach with this patient? Dr. Giese: I agree that she The diameter of her nipple-areola complex is for her breast The periareolar excision for a mastopexy can be In you do not have to a perfect circle of skin around the and in some in this patient, some of the periareolar skin may be this patient, I would not want to use the periareolar approach because I raising the nipple a great more than cm is a I would add a vertical scar component to get the breast shape that I would Dr. Colen: Dr. Hammond, it as if you quite about the periareolar approach in this What do you use in the periareolar to maintain the nipple in the new Dr. Hammond: The are the areola at about 52 mm or a diameter that is greater than what you ultimately need. When the periareolar opening is down with a it can into that opening without The is the outer I keep a little dermal along the of that entire periareolar opening. That is the of through which I can the Gore-Tex It will that suture very and allow of that opening with little the Gore-Tex suture a in the because it is strong, and But it also slides very easily through the of You can it and in your through that opening, and it control of the opening. you should as little as possible on the periareolar opening. Her large areolar diameter is because when you add an implant along with that large skin you are going to have on the periareolar Dr. Graf: I agree that the suture is very to the periareolar I think it is very to use the suture in this Dr. Colen: What suture are you Dr. Dr. Graf: In we do not have Gore-Tex we use Dr. Colen: Dr. Giese, what of suture do you use for the periareolar Dr. Giese: I use Gore-Tex on a just as Dr. Hammond described. I do that adding a vertical for the breast over the implant is a necessary option — at least in my — in such as when the periareolar approach may not suffice.