In this research, we explore the distinction between beliefs regarding the individual potential for people to change their socioeconomic class and beliefs regarding the contextual affordances of social mobility. We contend that the belief in the potential for individual social mobility reflects people’s attitude towards individual agency, effort, and determination, whereas beliefs in the contextual affordances for social mobility is more reflective of people’s understanding of the systemic forces that shape social class outcomes. Both are scored such that higher means greater opportunity for change. • Do these two interconnected beliefs reflect different, yet related, perspectives on the role of individual agency and systemic factors in shaping socioeconomic outcomes? • Because of their distinct emphases, do these beliefs have unique, and sometimes contrary, predictions regarding attitudes toward people in poverty? • Can both beliefs undermine support for public policies that seek to decrease inequality? • Can both beliefs be manipulated? • Can the manipulations impact prejudice and support?