论证理论
生成语法
计算机科学
脚手架
科学教育
生成模型
科学学习
数学教育
概念学习
教学方法
认知科学
人机交互
可视化方法
心理学
视觉学习
人工智能
构造(python库)
可视化
知识水平
定性研究
主动学习(机器学习)
科学推理
作者
Yu-Ren Lin,Xinyue Jiao,Cheng-Yu Hung
标识
DOI:10.1080/09500693.2026.2630293
摘要
In recent years, the educational impact of generative AI (GAI) has attracted growing attention, with student dependency emerging as a key concern. Given that GAI primarily relies on text-based interaction, this study designed an integrated visual scaffolding approach combining the Toulmin Argument Pattern (TAP) and the fishbone diagram to support students’ scientific argumentation learning. A quasi-experimental study involving 211 students compared three experimental conditions and one control group, manipulating two factors: (1) visual scaffolding (integrated vs. minimal) and (2) GAI support (present vs. removed after Topic 3). Students participated in find-the-difference argumentation tasks, constructing claims, warrants, rebuttals, and qualifiers based on images of natural phenomena. Results suggest that integrated visual scaffolding may complement text-based GAI support by sustaining learning motivation, facilitating knowledge application, and promoting diverse argument construction. After GAI withdrawal, students who continued to use visual scaffolding demonstrated more stable performance through peer interaction, particularly in constructing evidence-based warrants and rebuttals. These findings highlight the complementary role of visual scaffolds in GAI-supported learning and offer implications for learner-centred instructional design.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI