Atom Efficiency of Pd Sites for Methane Combustion: Single Atom Catalysts Versus Nanocatalysts

Methane combustion is an important reaction for energy production and methane removal from the atmosphere. This reaction highly relies on the use of noble metal Pd-based catalysts, which therefore drives the pursuit of catalysts with high atomic dispersion and activity. In this work, Pd/ceria catalysts dominated with Pd single atoms or nanosized Pd clusters (∼1 nm) are prepared and characterized by combining high-resolution high-angle annular dark-field scanning transmission electron microscopy (HAADF-STEM), in situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier-transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS), and Raman and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) techniques. By comparing the turnover frequencies (TOF; per every Pd atom) of Pd/ceria single atom catalysts and nanocatalysts, it is found that the atom efficiency of Pd is increased by 10 ∼30 times from single atom catalysts to nanocatalysts. For Pd single atom catalysts, although their activity can be tuned by changing the local structures, the intrinsic activity and number of active sites need to be further improved by engineering the surfaces of supports. For nanosized Pd species, despite the high TOF, the Pd atoms in the bulk structure are not directly participating in the catalytic reaction. This work highlights the importance of increasing the intrinsic activity of individual noble atoms, as well as the homogeneity of their local structures. For Pd/ceria systems reported in this work, our results indicate that from the application point of view, at the current stage, it is not practical to replace Pd nanocatalysts with single atom catalysts for methane combustion.