We investigate the mediating role of managing the emotions of others (MEOS) in the relationship between national narcissism (i.e., a defensive national identity that stems from unsatisfied needs and is linked to hostile intra- and intergroup behaviors) and willingness to conspire against one's own in-group. In two studies (Ns = 432 and 1000), conducted among nationwide samples of Poles, we found that national narcissism was positively linked to conspiracy intentions and that this relationship was accounted for by non-prosocial (i.e., manipulative) approach to managing the emotions of others. These effects were present even when we controlled for national identification, grandiose (Study 1 and 2), and hypersensitive (Study 2) individual narcissism. We discuss the role of emotion regulation in shaping intragroup processes.