摘要
Hydrogen production by electrolysis provides a sustainable energy vector, but current electrolyzers use ultrapure water. In some regions clean water is limited, but seawater is a widely available abundant resource. In a recent analysis, J. Niklas Hausmann and colleagues carry out a quantitative analysis to assess—does an economic case for direct seawater electrolysis exist? Hydrogen production by electrolysis provides a sustainable energy vector, but current electrolyzers use ultrapure water. In some regions clean water is limited, but seawater is a widely available abundant resource. In a recent analysis, J. Niklas Hausmann and colleagues carry out a quantitative analysis to assess—does an economic case for direct seawater electrolysis exist? Water electrolysis offers a way to use intermittent renewable energy resources to generate hydrogen, a fuel that can be used in transportation, heating, and as an energy store. This has led the research community to focus on improving existing technologies such as liquid alkaline and polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM) electrolyzers. A common feature of all currently available electrolyzers on the market is that they require a minimum of potable-grade water and subsequent additional purification systems generate high-quality deionized water, which is critical to ensure longevity of device components.1International Renewable Energy Agency. (2020). Green Hydrogen Cost Reduction: Scaling up Electrolysers to Meet the 1.5°C Climate Goal. Abu Dhabi.Google Scholar One of the benefits of a hydrogen economy is that it could lead to decentralization of energy systems. But a potential problem arises—in a world where high-purity water is not universally available, where do you source the water for electrolysis? Because seawater makes up >96% of global water, researchers have been increasingly seeking to develop catalysts, membranes, and electrolyzers that can work with seawater or low-grade surface water without further purification (Figure 1). On the face of it, this is an attractive option, bypassing the need for additional infrastructure such as desalination plants. However, seawater is a complex mixture of components and technical challenges need to be overcome to enable catalytic selectivity, prevent corrosion, and stop biofouling of the electrolyzer.2Tong W. Forster M. Dionigi F. Dresp S. Erami R.S. Strasser P. Cowan A.J. Farràs P. Electrolysis of Low-Grade and Saline Surface Water.Nat. Energy. 2020; 55: 367-377Crossref Scopus (209) Google Scholar,3Dresp S. Dionigi F. Klingenhof M. Strasser P. Direct Electrolytic Splitting of Seawater: Opportunities and Challenges.ACS Energy Lett. 2019; 4: 933-942Crossref Scopus (227) Google Scholar In a recent review article on the scientific challenges, we posed a question2Tong W. Forster M. Dionigi F. Dresp S. Erami R.S. Strasser P. Cowan A.J. Farràs P. Electrolysis of Low-Grade and Saline Surface Water.Nat. Energy. 2020; 55: 367-377Crossref Scopus (209) Google Scholar: does a cost-benefit to direct seawater splitting exist that makes addressing the scientific challenges worthwhile? Now, writing in Energy & Environmental Science, J. Niklas Hausmann and colleagues have addressed the economics for direct seawater splitting and compared it to a two-step scenario with a reverse osmosis plant to initially generate potable water (Figure 2).4Hausmann J.N. Schlögl R. Menezes P.W. Driess M. Is Direct Seawater Splitting Economically Meaningful?.Energy Environ. Sci. 2021; 14: 3679-3685Crossref Google Scholar On the basis of the efficiency and current costs of reverse osmosis, the authors come to the conclusion that the capital and operating costs of the initial purification of seawater is only a fraction of those associated with the electrolysis of pure water. This appears to be an open and shut case; with current technologies, direct seawater electrolysis makes no economic sense when an existing desalination plant already exists. But caution is needed. The authors recognize the challenge of the comparison of capital costs of reverse osmosis and electrolysis4Hausmann J.N. Schlögl R. Menezes P.W. Driess M. Is Direct Seawater Splitting Economically Meaningful?.Energy Environ. Sci. 2021; 14: 3679-3685Crossref Google Scholar because of the difference in maturity of technologies; advances in electrolyzer design and the effect of economies of scale will decrease the cost disparity. We also note that the differing electrochemical requirements mean that today’s established water electrolyzers are unlikely to be the devices of choice for direct seawater electrolysis. Among the most exciting developments is the emergence of anion exchange membrane (AEM) electrolyzers. These do not require precious metal catalysts, which represent the largest capex component of PEM, while offering some of PEM’s key benefits.5Miller H.A. Bouzek K. Hnat J. Loos S. Bernäcker C.I. Weißgärber T. Röntzsch L. Meier-Haack J. Green Hydrogen from Anion Exchange Membrane Water Electrolysis: A Review of Recent Developments in Critical Materials and Operating Conditions.Sustain. Energy Fuels. 2020; 4: 2114-2133Crossref Google Scholar AEM electrolysis might also overcome several technological barriers to direct seawater electrolysis;6Lindquist G.A. Xu Q. Oener S.Z. Boettcher S.W. Membrane Electrolyzers for Impure-Water Splitting.Joule. 2020; 4: 2549-2561Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (33) Google Scholar for example, commercial AEMs use water feeds with carbonate concentrations5Miller H.A. Bouzek K. Hnat J. Loos S. Bernäcker C.I. Weißgärber T. Röntzsch L. Meier-Haack J. Green Hydrogen from Anion Exchange Membrane Water Electrolysis: A Review of Recent Developments in Critical Materials and Operating Conditions.Sustain. Energy Fuels. 2020; 4: 2114-2133Crossref Google Scholar at or higher than that found in seawater, and some catalysts can operate effectively, and even show improved activity, in the presence of chloride.7Dresp S. Dionigi F. Klingenhof M. Merzdorf T. Schmies H. Drnec J. Poulain A. Strasser P. Molecular Understanding of the Impact of Saline Contaminants and Alkaline PH on NiFe Layered Double Hydroxide Oxygen Evolution Catalysts.ACS Catal. 2021; 11: 6800-6809Crossref Scopus (17) Google Scholar The economic analyses presented4Hausmann J.N. Schlögl R. Menezes P.W. Driess M. Is Direct Seawater Splitting Economically Meaningful?.Energy Environ. Sci. 2021; 14: 3679-3685Crossref Google Scholar are important to inform design decisions today, but these need to be regularly revisited because both the technological and economic arguments change. Regardless of the water source, technological breakthroughs are critical in enabling low-cost green hydrogen. A second report in the same journal,8Khan M.A. Al-Attas T. Roy S. Rahman M.M. Ghaffour N. Thangadurai V. Larter S. Hu J. Ajayan P.M. Kibria M.G. Seawater Electrolysis for Hydrogen Production: A Solution Looking for a Problem?.Energy Environ. Sci. 2021; https://doi.org/10.1039/D1EE00870FCrossref Google Scholar suggests refocusing research efforts away from direct seawater electrolysis and to invest in desalination systems. In our opinion, basic and applied research in the field is critical to solve other well-known challenges and to bring down the cost of electrolysis; for example, poor water quality is one of the main reasons for stack failure in PEM electrolyzers.1International Renewable Energy Agency. (2020). Green Hydrogen Cost Reduction: Scaling up Electrolysers to Meet the 1.5°C Climate Goal. Abu Dhabi.Google Scholar This is why we believe that continuing high-quality, basic research on direct seawater splitting is of fundamental importance because it provides technological solutions to handling impurities and knowledge on feed purity requirements and degradation benefiting the entire field of electrolysis.7Dresp S. Dionigi F. Klingenhof M. Merzdorf T. Schmies H. Drnec J. Poulain A. Strasser P. Molecular Understanding of the Impact of Saline Contaminants and Alkaline PH on NiFe Layered Double Hydroxide Oxygen Evolution Catalysts.ACS Catal. 2021; 11: 6800-6809Crossref Scopus (17) Google Scholar We hope that this work4Hausmann J.N. Schlögl R. Menezes P.W. Driess M. Is Direct Seawater Splitting Economically Meaningful?.Energy Environ. Sci. 2021; 14: 3679-3685Crossref Google Scholar triggers more detailed discussions of the economics, in particular on the effect of scale. Reverse osmosis plants are large installations, typically producing from 10,000 to close to 1 million m3 of water per day.9Caldera U. Breyer C. Learning Curve for Seawater Reverse Osmosis Desalination Plants: Capital Cost Trend of the Past, Present, and Future.Water Resour. Res. 2017; 53: 10523-10538Crossref Scopus (63) Google Scholar There is a dramatic mismatch of scale with commercial electrolyzers, the largest available are 10 MW, requiring ∼125 m3 water a day. The biggest single factor controlling capex of reverse osmosis is plant size,9Caldera U. Breyer C. Learning Curve for Seawater Reverse Osmosis Desalination Plants: Capital Cost Trend of the Past, Present, and Future.Water Resour. Res. 2017; 53: 10523-10538Crossref Scopus (63) Google Scholar so we caution the use of costs from large installations. The feasibility of construction of dedicated desalination sites for intermittent, small-scale decentralized H2 production needs addressing. Alongside the economics of size of installation, it is also important to consider the system footprint. Hydrogen from seawater is of particular interest to the marine industry. Techno-economic models suggests that hydrogen production at offshore wind farms is competitive with direct electricity transmission to shore for distances >40–50 km.10Franco B.A. Baptista P. Neto R.C. Ganilha S. Assessment of Offloading Pathways for Wind-Powered Offshore Hydrogen Production: Energy and Economic Analysis.Appl. Energy. 2021; 286: 116553Crossref Scopus (19) Google Scholar Here, the footprint of the installation is critical, with cost and safety implications due to the requirement of restriction zones around hydrogen installations, and a smaller integrated one-step system, becomes highly desirable. We conclude that the recent economic analyses4Hausmann J.N. Schlögl R. Menezes P.W. Driess M. Is Direct Seawater Splitting Economically Meaningful?.Energy Environ. Sci. 2021; 14: 3679-3685Crossref Google Scholar,8Khan M.A. Al-Attas T. Roy S. Rahman M.M. Ghaffour N. Thangadurai V. Larter S. Hu J. Ajayan P.M. Kibria M.G. Seawater Electrolysis for Hydrogen Production: A Solution Looking for a Problem?.Energy Environ. Sci. 2021; https://doi.org/10.1039/D1EE00870FCrossref Google Scholar are important because they demonstrate that availability of fresh water should not be seen as a barrier to the implementation of a green hydrogen economy. On the basis of current PEM and liquid alkaline technologies, the economic and energy arguments favor a two-step process for large centralized electrolysis installations. But we urge caution, as with many aspects of energy science, a one-size fits all solution is unlikely to be appropriate, with the size and location of installation being critical in assessing the viability of seawater electrolysis. As technologies advance and economies of scale change, it is important to regularly revisit these economic analyses. All agree that green hydrogen from seawater is likely to become an important approach; the question remains the same, direct from the sea or not to be? A.C. and P.F. acknowledge financial support from INTERREG Atlantic Area program ( EAPA_190/2016 , SEAFUEL), and P.S. acknowledges funding from German BMWi under 03EIV041F and BMBF under 03HY302Q (“H2Mare/PtXWind”) and 03SF0611A (“H2Meer”).