摘要
In this issue of Chem, Wang and co-workers report an innovative strategy for activating inert N2 molecules through hydrogen bonding for efficient photocatalytic nitrogen fixation. This preview carefully discusses the mechanism, presents the challenges associated with photocatalytic nitrogen fixation, and proposes methods for enhancing its performance in the future. In this issue of Chem, Wang and co-workers report an innovative strategy for activating inert N2 molecules through hydrogen bonding for efficient photocatalytic nitrogen fixation. This preview carefully discusses the mechanism, presents the challenges associated with photocatalytic nitrogen fixation, and proposes methods for enhancing its performance in the future. Nitrogen fixation is an essential process in the nitrogen cycle, where the inert atmospheric dinitrogen (N2) is converted to ammonia (NH3), providing nitrogen sources for the synthesis of life-supporting components (proteins, nucleic acids, etc.) and crucial industrial products (fertilizers, dyes, explosives, etc.). Nitrogen fixation not only occurs naturally through certain bacteria but also proceeds through the industrial Haber-Bosch process for the mass production of fertilizers. However, the Haber-Bosch process requires high pressure (>200 atm) and temperature (300°C−500°C) input and methane as the hydrogen source, making the process highly energy intensive and environment polluting. Electrocatalytic nitrogen fixation is a clean route for NH3 production under mild conditions, but it inevitably consumes tremendous electricity because of the chemical inertness of nitrogen, large overpotential of the process, and low faradic efficiency toward NH3.1Martín A.J. Shinagawa T. Pérez-Ramírez J. Electrocatalytic reduction of nitrogen: from Haber-Bosch to ammonia artificial leaf.Chem. 2019; 5: 263-283Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (214) Google Scholar Photocatalytic nitrogen fixation, on the other hand, is a more sustainable pathway because it is driven by the renewable solar energy and utilizes Earth-abundant H2O and N2. In a typical N2 photofixation process, the photocatalyst absorbs light to generate electron-hole pairs (Figure 1, step i), which migrate to the photocatalyst surface (Figure 1, step ii) and react with H+ and N2 dissolved in the aqueous solution (Figure 1, step iii). However, N2 photofixation suffers from low light-absorption efficiency and fast charge-carrier recombination (Figure 1, step i′). Also, it is extremely challenging to activate the highly stable N2 molecules, where a dissociation energy of 945 kJ/mol needs to be overcome. In this issue of Chem, Wang and co-workers report an innovative strategy for effectively activating N2 molecules via hydrogen bonding by using porous Cu modified by S atoms (3%-S/Cu).2Xin Y. Wang S. Yuan H. Hou T. Zhu W. Liu Y. Yao Y. Zhang W. Liang S. Wang L. Atomic-level insights into the activation of nitrogen via hydrogen-bond interaction toward nitrogen photofixation.Chem. 2021; 7: 2118-2136Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (14) Google Scholar Mechanistic studies revealed that the surface S atoms participate in the photocatalytic process by accepting H atoms in the form of S−H and donating them for N2 activation via hydrogen-bond interaction. In the Raman spectra of 3%-S/Cu, the S−H band emerged upon the adsorption of water vapor and diminished after the introduction of N2 under irradiation, illustrating the existence of the S−H intermediate. In situ N K-edge XANES spectra exhibited an elongated N−N bond in the N2 adsorbate in the presence of H2O, indicating that H2O aided N2 activation. In addition, density functional theory (DFT) suggested that N2 molecules were adsorbed by S/Cu(111) to form N2∗-S/Cu(111), which was further stabilized by a H atom as NN-H∗-S/Cu(111). The activation energy of the rate-limiting step was 0.87 eV on S/Cu(111), significantly lower than that on Cu(111) (1.52 eV), Cu2S(111) (1.88 eV), and Cu2S/Cu(111) (1.95 eV). These results indicate that hydrogen-bond interaction enhanced the activation of N2 molecules and contributed to the remarkable activity toward the nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR). Moreover, 3%-Cu/S remained active under visible (>400 nm) to near-infrared (630 nm) light as a result of plasmon-induced light absorption by Cu. The work also highlights the importance of rigorous quantification and source tracing of the NH3 product, which guarantee that NH3 is precisely measured and derived only from the NRR. The NH3 concentration was measured by four different methods: the indophenol blue method, Nessler’s reagent method, the ion chromatograph (IC) method, and the 1H NMR method. All methods rendered comparable values under the same measurement conditions, suggesting high validity of the measured values. Moreover, the authors endeavored to rule out possible contamination sources for NH3 production. For instance, NH3 contaminants and NOx species are widely present in commercial N2 gas cylinders, which must be either preemptively removed or recorded as background signals and subtracted. The authors pretreated the feed gas with Cu-SSZ-13 zeolite to eliminate the NH3 and NOx, the absence of which was certified by the IC method. NH3 can also derive from nitrate impurities in chemical reagents or on photocatalysts. In this work, although a trace amount of nitrate was detected on the photocatalysts, the possibility of NH3 production from nitrate was ruled out because nitrate addition failed to photocatalytically produce NH3 in the absence of N2. These control experiments indicate that NH3 indeed originated from the NRR. The authors performed an isotope-labeling test with 15N2 to further verify the origin of the nitrogen in NH3, and an equal amount of 15NH3 was produced under the same conditions. To confirm the hydrogen source in NH3, the authors replaced H2O with CH3CN, which was unable to produce protons. No NH3 generation was detected under such conditions, indicating that the hydrogen in NH3 arose from protons. Furthermore, O2 evolution was detected during the photocatalytic process, which was produced via the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) (Figure 1). All of these experiments prove that NH3 was generated by the coupling of activated N2 with protons in the water solution. The activation of N2 through hydrogen bonding presents an innovative strategy for enhancing the performance of N2 photofixation, yet other important issues could be considered to further boost the NH3 yield. The first issue is to increase the selectivity toward the NRR over the side hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) (Figure 1, step iv). From a thermodynamic point of view, the HER is more favorable because the reduction potential for the first electron transfer (N2 + e− + H+ → N2H) is −3.2 V versus the normal hydrogen electrode (NHE). In terms of kinetics, N2 conversion to NH3 is inherently a complicated process involving the transfer of six electrons and combination with six protons produced by the OER (Figure 1, step v), whereas the HER is a simple two-electron process. Moreover, N2 is hardly soluble in water (0.7 mmol N2/kg H2O at 20°C and 1 atm),3Kaye G.W.C. Laby T.H. Tables of Physical and Chemical Constants.Fifteenth Edition. John Wiley and Sons, 1986Google Scholar further hindering N2 adsorption to the photocatalyst surface. Another important issue is that NH3 tends to decompose back to H2 and N2 (Figure 1, step vi). The solubility of NH3 (28 mol NH3/kg H2O at 20°C and 1 atm) in water is 4–5 orders of magnitude higher than that of N2 or H2 (0.8 mmol H2/kg H2O at 20°C and 1 atm),3Kaye G.W.C. Laby T.H. Tables of Physical and Chemical Constants.Fifteenth Edition. John Wiley and Sons, 1986Google Scholar which is highly favorable for NH3 decomposition, especially at high concentrations. Thus, a comprehensive mechanism of the HER and NH3 decomposition reaction needs to be thoroughly investigated, and it is also of great importance to decrease the corresponding kinetic rate constants as much as possible. Wang and colleagues’ work emphasizes the importance of accurate quantification of NH3. To contribute to this field, Yu et al. highlight a rapid and accurate NH3 analytical method.4Yu W. Lewis N.S. Gray H.B. Dalleska N.F. Isotopically selective quantification by UPLC-MS of aqueous ammonia at submicromolar concentrations using dansyl chloride derivatization.ACS Energy Lett. 2020; 5: 1532-1536Crossref Scopus (24) Google Scholar This method is based on the dansyl chloride derivatization reaction and detects NH3 at sub-micromolar concentrations while being immune to contamination. The authors conducted the measurement by adding excessive dansyl chloride to convert all NH4+ in the analyte to DNS-NH2 and then quantified DNS-14NH2 and its isotopologue (DNS-15NH2) via liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. Ambient 14NH3 contaminant remarkably increased the concentration of DNS-14NH2, whereas the DNS-15NH2 signal was unaffected. Using isotope-labeled 15N2 as the feed gas, this method enables quantification of 15NH3 generated from 15N2 photofixation and 14NH3 originating from ambient 14NH3 contamination. Another critical challenge is to achieve breakthrough activity of N2 photofixation through the rational design of photocatalysts. Single-component photocatalysts usually fail to efficiently utilize solar energy while maintaining strong redox potentials because of the trade-off between the range of light absorption and redox powers of photogenerated charge carriers.5Xia Y. Yu J. Reaction: rational design of highly active photocatalysts for CO2 conversion.Chem. 2020; 6: 1039-1040Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (79) Google Scholar Constructing an S-scheme heterojunction provides a development roadmap for next-generation photocatalysts because of its capacity to simultaneously retain broad light absorption and strong redox abilities.6Xu Q. Zhang L. Cheng B. Fan J. Yu J. S-scheme heterojunction photocatalyst.Chem. 2020; 6: 1543-1559Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (1101) Google Scholar,7Cheng C. He B. Fan J. Cheng B. Cao S. Yu J. An inorganic/organic S-scheme heterojunction H2-production photocatalyst and its charge transfer mechanism.Adv. Mater. 2021; 33: e2100317Crossref PubMed Scopus (290) Google Scholar Moreover, surface defects and metal dopants have been proposed to be the active sites for the chemisorption and activation of N2 molecules, yet defects and dopants are usually considered recombination centers for electron-hole pairs in photocatalysis, decreasing the separation efficiency of photoinduced charge carriers.8Zhou W. Fu H. Defect-mediated electron-hole separation in semiconductor photocatalysis.Inorg. Chem. Front. 2018; 5: 1240-1254Crossref Google Scholar To avoid the flaws of defects and dopants, researchers could alternatively create active centers for N2 activation by introducing co-catalysts, which could trap and separate photoinduced charge carriers, enhance N2 adsorption and activation, and decrease the overpotential of reduction reactions.9Meng A. Zhang L. Cheng B. Yu J. Dual cocatalysts in TiO2 photocatalysis.Adv. Mater. 2019; 31: e1807660Crossref PubMed Scopus (566) Google Scholar In summary, artificial N2 photofixation is a promising approach for the convenient, clean, and sustainable production of NH3. However, it is difficult to overcome theoretical and technical obstacles, such as effectively adsorbing and activating N2, suppressing side reactions and NH3 decomposition, implementing rigorous NH3 detection methods, and developing high-performance photocatalysts. This preview highlights an innovative strategy reported by Wang and co-workers for N2 activation via hydrogen bonding and then discusses N2 photofixation on a wider scope, including common challenges in achieving higher production and plausible solutions to deal with these problems. We anticipate that this preview will not only comprehensively present the fundamentals and current status of photocatalytic N2 fixation but also inspire future research in this field. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (nos. 51932007, 51961135303, and U1705251). Atomic-level insights into the activation of nitrogen via hydrogen-bond interaction toward nitrogen photofixationXin et al.ChemApril 14, 2021In BriefPorous Cu with surface modification of S atoms (3%-S/Cu) revealed remarkable catalytic activity and stability toward N2 photofixation. Further mechanistic studies indicated that forming S–H bonds on porous Cu significantly enhanced the activation of N2 molecules via hydrogen-bond interaction, directly contributing to excellent catalytic performance. Full-Text PDF Open Archive