Product recalls pose significant challenges across supply chains, making high product quality essential to reducing recall likelihood and mitigating associated costs. This study examines a supply chain where a manufacturer sells through a retailer while considering the risk of a quality-related recall and subsequent recovery. Using a game-theoretic model, we evaluate four collaborative contracts-Typical Cost Sharing (TCS), Cost Sharing through Bargaining (CSB), Typical Revenue Sharing (TRS), and Revenue Sharing through Bargaining (RSB)-to identify the most effective approach for improving quality and maximizing profits. Results show that all contracts outperform a non-collaborative (NC) setup, with RSB driving the highest quality, lowest recall probability, and greatest profitability for the manufacturer and the entire supply chain. While the retailer prefers TRS, the manufacturer can use profit-sharing to incentivize the adoption of the superior RSB contract.