Cells use flavin monooxygenases to break down foreign molecules by adding oxygen atoms to them. Biochemists have long assumed that the enzymes use a particular cofactor adduct to add the oxygen. A new study suggests that some of these enzymes use a different adduct—one that significantly changes the reaction mechanism. A team led by Robin Teufel of the University of Freiburg reports that some flavin monooxygenases use a flavin cofactor with a peroxide attached to the molecule’s N5 nitrogen (Nat. Chem. Biol. 2020, DOI: 10.1038/s41589-020-0476-2). Most known monooxygenases instead have a peroxide attached to a carbon at C4a on the flavin cofactor. The change in where the peroxide forms leads to unexpected reactions. A peroxide oxygen nucleophilically attacks the substrate, which gets oxygenated but not oxidized. “It allows the enzymes to attack rather unreactive substrates such as modified aromatic rings and cleave these relatively stable bonds,” Teufel says. To figure