摘要
Emotional/symbolic and functional place attachments were measured on the Green and Colorado Rivers in Canyonlands National Park and at Mount Rushmore National Memorial. Although Canyonlands and Mount Rushmore represent very different recreational settings, it was possible to measure both types of attachment by using 12 place attachment statements. In Canyonlands, river users on the Green and Colorado Rivers demonstrated different motives for taking a river trip and different levels of acceptance for potential management actions, based on respondents’ level of agreement with place attachment statements. Compared to river users with relatively high agreement on the Colorado River, Green River users with relatively high levels of agreement indicated a stronger desire for wildland experiences. Sense of place, also referred to as place attachment, has been recognized in disciplines such as geography and architecture since the early 1970s. In recent years, place attachment has gained increasing scientific interest in the field of resource management (Williams and Stewart 1998; Moore and Graefe 1994; Mitchell and others 1993). This study sought to show the potential utility of place attachment as a resource management tool. Specifically, the intent was to show an ability to measure place attachment in different types of recreational settings: a backcountry setting (Canyonlands National Park) and a front-country setting (Mount Rushmore National Memorial). Another objective of the study—specifically in Canyonlands National Park—was to determine whether river users who demonstrated differing levels of agreement concerning place attachment on the Green and Colorado Rivers responded differently to questions about trip motives and potential management actions. An affinity for different motives and management actions could demonstrate a need for management plans that address differing recreational needs of users on these two rivers. Two types of place attachment were measured: emotional/ symbolic and functional. Emotional/symbolic attachment, also referred to as place identity (Stokols and Shumaker 1981, Schreyer and others 1981), refers to the emotional or symbolic ties an individual may feel for a specific place. Personal emotional ties to a frequently visited park could represent this type of place attachment. Emotional/symbolic attachment also may be expressed as an identity with a symbolic meaning or idea. For example, an individual may identify with the idea of heritage, as symbolized by the National Park System, or the idea of wilderness. Functional attachment, also referred to as place dependence (Stokels and Shumaker 1981; Schreyer and others 1981), describes the use of a resource to satisfy a need or goal. In a recreational setting, functional attachment often is related to the activity an individual may pursue in the context of the resource. Some activities are passive, such as viewing scenery, whereas others, such as whitewater rafting, involve close physical contact with the resource. The constructs of emotional/symbolic attachment and functional attachment have been presented in other recreational studies in the past ten years (Moore and Graefe 1994; Mitchell and others 1993; Williams and others 1992). Study Areas ____________________ Canyonlands National Park, a backcountry setting, is in southeastern Utah. The Park encompasses 527 square miles and provides opportunities for numerous recreational activities, including hiking, camping, backpacking, mountain biking, four-wheeling and river running. Within park boundaries, the Green and Colorado Rivers offer river runners opportunities for several types of river experiences. Above the confluence, the calm waters of the Green and Colorado Rivers present favorable conditions for flatwater river trips. Several miles below the confluence of the two rivers, the Colorado River flows through Cataract Canyon, offering river runners approximately 14 miles of whitewater and 28 rapids (with difficulty ratings of up to class 5). The Green River is popular with canoers and kayakers and receives less motorized traffic than the Colorado River. Conversely, the Colorado River receives more commercial use (guided trips) than the Green River. Managers at Canyonlands are currently in the process of developing an updated river management plan for the Green and Colorado Rivers. The place attachment study was conducted as part of a larger visitor use study to gather a variety of data about river users (Warzecha and others 1999). Mount Rushmore National Memorial, a front-country setting, is in southwestern South Dakota. The Memorial is considered a tribute to the birth, growth, preservation and development of the United States. The primary resource is