活动记录
多导睡眠图
卡帕
睡眠(系统调用)
睡眠阶段
阶段(地层学)
睡眠开始
医学
听力学
慢波睡眠
科恩卡帕
活动追踪器
睡眠起始潜伏期
脑电图
物理疗法
心理学
物理医学与康复
昼夜节律
失眠症
计算机科学
内科学
体力活动
精神科
数学
机器学习
古生物学
操作系统
生物
几何学
作者
Ju Lynn Ong,Hosein Aghayan Golkashani,Shohreh Ghorbani,Kian Foong Wong,Nicholas I Y N Chee,Adrian R. Willoughby,Michael W.L. Chee
出处
期刊:Sleep Health
[Elsevier BV]
日期:2023-12-11
卷期号:10 (1): 9-23
被引量:77
标识
DOI:10.1016/j.sleh.2023.11.005
摘要
Evaluate the performance of 6 wearable sleep trackers across 4 classes (EEG-based headband, research-grade actigraphy, iteratively improved consumer tracker, low-cost consumer tracker). Dreem 3 headband, Actigraph GT9X, Oura Ring Gen3, Fitbit Sense, Xiaomi Mi Band 7, Axtro Fit3. In-lab polysomnography with 3-reader, consensus sleep scoring. Sixty participants (26 males) across 3 age groups (18-30, 31-50, and 51-70 years). Overnight in a sleep laboratory from habitual sleep time to wake time. Discrepancy and epoch-by-epoch analyses for sleep/wake (2-stage) and sleep-stage (4-stage; wake/light/deep/rapid eye movement) classification (devices vs. polysomnography). EEG-based Dreem performed the best (2-stage kappa = 0.76, 4-stage kappa = 0.76-0.86) with the lowest total sleep time, sleep efficiency, sleep onset latency, and wake after sleep onset discrepancies vs. polysomnography. This was followed by the iteratively improved consumer trackers: Oura (2-stage kappa = 0.64, 4-stage kappa = 0.55-0.70) and Fitbit (2-stage kappa = 0.58, 4-stage kappa = 0.45-0.60) which had comparable total sleep time and sleep efficiency discrepancies that outperformed accelerometry-only Actigraph (2-stage kappa = 0.47). The low-cost consumer trackers had poorest overall performance (2-stage kappa < 0.31, 4-stage kappa < 0.33). Proportional biases were driven by nights with poorer sleep (longer sleep onset latencies and/or wake after sleep onset). EEG-based Dreem is recommended when evaluating poor quality sleep or when highest accuracy sleep-staging is required. Iteratively improved non-EEG sleep trackers (Oura, Fitbit) balance classification accuracy with well-tolerated, and economic deployment at-scale, and are recommended for studies involving mostly healthy sleepers. The low-cost trackers, can log time in bed but are not recommended for research use.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI