Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale (1986) depicts a dystopian world marked by environmental toxicity, rising numbers of physical deformities, and declining fertility, which pose concerns for the future of humankind. Informed by recent developments in new material feminisms, this article shows the limitations of the ecofeminist approach as it addresses the oppression of women and nature by highlighting the overlooked agency of materials within the oppressive Gileadean regime. It further elucidates the complex interaction between human bodies and toxicants as a response to male exploitation, which ultimately results in the containment of the regime and the erosion of male authority. Drawing on new material feminist theories such as Karen Barad’s neologism of “intra-actions” and Stacy Alaimo’s concept of “trans-corporeality,” this article sheds light on how The Handmaid’s Tale highlights the intricate interplay among toxic substances, human bodies, and male political culture, thereby prompting a rethinking of the human-nature relationship as an alternative approach to confronting patriarchal societal norms and anthropocentrism.