Two-dimensional (2D) magnetic materials are promising candidates for spintronics and quantum technologies. One extensively studied example is the ferromagnetic (FM) ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$ monolayer with the honeycomb ${\mathrm{Cr}}^{3+}$ (${t}_{2g}^{3}, S$ = 3/2) spin lattice, while ${\mathrm{VPS}}_{3}$ has the same honeycomb $S$ = 3/2 spin lattice (${\mathrm{V}}^{2+}, {t}_{2g}^{3}$) but displays N\'eel antiferromagnetism. In this paper, we study the electronic structure and particularly the contrasting magnetism of ${\mathrm{VPS}}_{3}$ and ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$ monolayers, using density functional calculations, magnetic exchange pictures, maximally localized Wannier function (MLWF) analysis, and parallel tempering Monte Carlo simulations. We find that ${\mathrm{VPS}}_{3}$ is a Mott-Hubbard insulator but ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$ is a charge-transfer insulator, and therefore their magnetic exchange mechanisms are essentially different. The first-nearest-neighbor (1NN) direct $d\text{\ensuremath{-}}d$ exchange dominates in ${\mathrm{VPS}}_{3}$, thus leading to a strong antiferromagnetic (AF) coupling. However, the formation of vanadium vacancies, associated with instability of the low-valence ${\mathrm{V}}^{2+}$ ions, suppresses the AF coupling and thus strongly reduces the N\'eel temperature (${T}_{N}$) in line with experimental observation. In contrast, our results reveal that the major 1NN $d\text{\ensuremath{-}}p\text{\ensuremath{-}}d$ superexchanges in ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$ via different channels give rise to competing FM and AF couplings, ultimately resulting in a weak FM coupling as observed experimentally. After revisiting several important superexchange channels reported in the literature, based on our MLWF and tight-binding analyses, we note that some antiphase contributions must be subtly and simultaneously considered, and thus we provide a deeper insight into the FM coupling of ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$. Moreover, we identify and compare the major contributions to the magnetic anisotropy, i.e., a weak shape anisotropy in ${\mathrm{VPS}}_{3}$ and a relatively strong exchange anisotropy in ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$. Our paper offers a comprehensive understanding of 2D magnetism using spin-orbital states and distinct exchange channels.