Coin cells are widely used for the development of new electrode materials or electrolytes before validation in application oriented formats. However, electrochemical results differ between cell formats. The origins of these format dependent aging are still under discussion. Here, the aging behaviour of coin and pouch cells (NMC811 || graphite or graphite + 10% SiO x ) assembled with identical electrodes, separators and electrolytes is compared. Unlike pouch cells, coin cells consistently exhibit accelerated capacity loss during cyclic aging (20 °C, 40 °C and 60 °C) and calendar aging at 0% and 100% state of charge. The discrepancy between coin and pouch cells during cyclic aging increases with temperature. The results reveal an additional temperature- and time-dependent, but potential- and cycle-independent aging mechanism in coin cells, reducing transferability between the two formats. Several factors, including pressure, electrolyte amount, additive amount, lithium plating and resistance, were excluded as the main origin. Instead, ion chromatography–mass spectrometry reveals an increased difluorophosphate concentration in the coin cell electrolyte, indicating enhanced LiPF 6 hydrolysis, most probably caused by insufficient hermetic sealing of the coin cell housing. Sealing such coin cells in an additional pouch bag suppresses hydrolysis and improves comparability between coin and pouch cells, particularly at higher temperature.