We investigated two related mindsets about the malleable or fixed nature of socioeconomic mobility and their distinct influences on stigma toward those in poverty. Across four studies, conducted in the United States ( N = 1,057), we explored mindsets about individual potential to change social class, what we called individual mobility mindsets (I_MM), and mindsets about societal opportunities for socioeconomic mobility, or societal mobility mindsets (S_MM). Although the mindsets were positively correlated, they had distinct focal points and, importantly, they differentially predicted outcomes. For example, I_MM was positively linked to individual-level attributes like grit, whereas S_MM was negatively linked to systemic attributions for social class and to beliefs that inequality is unjust. Additionally, I_MM was negatively related to stigma toward those in poverty, whereas S_MM was positively linked to it. This was largely due to the differential links to essentialism—that is, to the view that poverty is an inherent and defining characteristic. Although both types of mindsets were positively linked to blame, which is a known driver of stigma, I_MM was negatively linked to essentialism and S_MM was positively linked to it. We discuss different models of mindsets and stigma.