Prior research on the tenor of media coverage has significantly advanced our understanding of how firms react to negative evaluations of the media. Less is known about how firms attract positive or negative media coverage in the first place. Since media build their perception holistically on a combination of multiple elements, we suggest that media coverage is, in fact, the result of a nexus of firm signals that should be considered in combination rather than in isolation. In this paper, we investigate what complex combinations of signals lead to positive or negative media coverage. The context for our study is the media’s assessment of the environmental behavior of firms operating in the electric utility sector. Our analyses, based on fsQCA methodology, suggest that it is particularly the relative strength and the level of (in)congruence of signals that drive the direction of media coverage in complex ways. This paper contributes to our understanding of how the media form their assessments about a firm posture in the light of interdependent, simultaneously existing firm-level signals.