医学
利益相关者
指南
癌症疼痛
质量(理念)
范围(计算机科学)
清晰
家庭医学
物理疗法
替代医学
公共关系
病理
化学
程序设计语言
哲学
认识论
生物化学
计算机科学
政治学
作者
Virginie Piano,Annelies Schalkwijk,Jako Burgers,Stans Verhagen,Hans G. Kress,Yechiel A. Hekster,Michel Lantéri‐Minet,Yvonne Engels,Kris Vissers
出处
期刊:Pain Practice
[Wiley]
日期:2012-10-16
卷期号:13 (5): 349-357
被引量:27
标识
DOI:10.1111/j.1533-2500.2012.00602.x
摘要
Abstract Between 19% and 39% of patients with cancer pain suffer from neuropathic pain. Its diagnosis and treatment is still challenging. Yet, national clinical practice guidelines ( CPG s) have been developed in several E uropean countries to assist practitioners in managing these patients safely and legally. The aim of this study was to assess the quality of the development and reporting of these CPG s. Methods In collaboration with the E uropean F ederation of IASP Chapters, a E uropean inventory of CPG s was conducted. Inclusion criteria were at least one paragraph dedicated to the treatment of neuropathic pain in cancer. Using the Appraisal of Guidelines, Research and Evaluation II instrument, 2 appraisers independently assessed the quality of the development process of the included CPG s in 6 quality domains. Besides, CPG s developed by governmental organization were compared with those developed by professional societies using t ‐tests. Results Mean scores of the domains “scope and purpose” (80%) and “clarity of presentation” (61%) were satisfactory, “stakeholder involvement” (58%), “rigor of development” (57%), and “editorial independence” (53%) were acceptable, and “applicability” was insufficient (39%). Governmental guidelines had higher quality scores than professional society guidelines for domain “stakeholder involvement” and “editorial independence” ( P < 0.01). Conclusions The quality of the development process of the 9 included CPG s varied widely. CPG s should be developed within a structured guideline program, including methodological support. As developing a CPG is expensive and time‐consuming, we recommend more international cooperation to increase quality and lower the development costs.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI