经颅直流电刺激
磁刺激
医学
深部经颅磁刺激
萧条(经济学)
物理医学与康复
脑刺激
神经科学
精神科
电流(流体)
精神分裂症(面向对象编程)
刺激
神经调节
难治性抑郁症
心理学
重性抑郁障碍
系统回顾
物理疗法
作者
Derek Fisk,T William,Rae Paulene Spiwak,Mandana Modirrousta,Ji Hyun Ko,Jitender Sareen
标识
DOI:10.1016/j.psychres.2025.116902
摘要
BACKGROUND: Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) and transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) have been thoroughly explored in the treatment of various psychiatric disorders and neuropsychiatric symptoms. However, whether combining rTMS and tDCS can safely and effectively treat psychiatric conditions remains unknown. In this systematic review, we seek to summarize all existing studies that have combined rTMS and tDCS to remedy psychiatric disorders and symptoms. METHODS: We searched four databases in addition to grey literature to identify relevant studies. All abstracts and manuscripts were independently reviewed by two reviewers. For inclusion, studies necessarily consisted of those who received both rTMS and tDCS for a psychiatric condition or symptom. RESULTS: Fourteen studies were reviewed, which had relevance to unipolar depression (five), bipolar disorder (two), obsessive-compulsive disorder (two), Alzheimer's Disease (one), chronic insomnia (two), depressive and anxiety symptoms (one) and stress (one). In three RCTs on unipolar depression, the group receiving both rTMS and tDCS experienced significant reductions in mean Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) scores (by 18.22, 16.59 and 20.04) as well as response rates (83.33 % and 91.7 %) and remission rates (83.3 %) - all of which were generally superior compared to treatment with rTMS or tDCS alone. For chronic insomnia, one RCT noted greater improvements in sleep quality/efficiency and depressive symptoms compared to monotherapy. The type and frequency of side effects were comparable to monotherapy, and no significant adverse events were reported. CONCLUSION: The existing evidence suggests that combining rTMS and tDCS alone yields greater symptomatic benefit for unipolar depression compared to either treatment alone. Further studies involving additional protocols and disorders could elucidate the utility of combined treatment.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI