作者
Crescioli, Elena,Nielsen, Frederik Mølgaard,Thomas Lass Klitgaard,Martin Siegemund,Poulsen, Lone M.,Andreasen, Anne Sofie,Bestle, Morten,Iversen, Susanne,Anne Craveiro Brøchner,Bunzel, Anne-Marie Gellert,Broberg Eriksen, Anne Sofie,Grøfte, Thorbjørn,Laake, Jon Henrik,Hildebrandt, Thomas,Lange, Theis,Anders Perner,Olav Lilleholt Schjørring,Bodil Steen Rasmussen
摘要
Introduction: Intubation with an endotracheal tube (ETT) is a widelyused technique in anesthesiology and intensive care units (1). Afterinsertion, the ETT have to be secured to prevent its mobilization,unplanned extubation being specifically dreaded. To date, there are noformal recommendations about securing systems, and various practicesare observed (2). A few studies have compared the resistance toextubation of these securing systems. Nevertheless, the forced extubationmethod was not rigorously standardized [manual traction (3) orcounterweight release (4)]. In addition, forced extubation was definedas either an ETT mobilization with a magnitude chosen arbitrarily (4)or a modification of the securing system (5) (breakage, detachment).However, in real life practice, extubation does not systematically occuralong with these events.Objectives: The main objective of this prospective study with rigorousmonitoring conditions was to compare the ability of widely used ETTsecuring systems to withstand a tensile stress simulating extubationon a mannequin. Four conditions of traction were evaluated: 2 speeds(5 and 50 cm/min) and 2 traction plans (sagittal and frontal).Methods: This study was approved by the national Ethics Committeefor Anesthesia and Critical Care Research on November 11, 2022 (IRB00010254‐2022-114). Along with the absence of securing system (control),6 securing systems were assessed: 3 using cord (single, with knot,with adhesive band), 2 using adhesive elastic band (short 35 cm bandand long 65 cm band) and, one standalone marketed device. A uniquetype of ETT was used (7.5 mm internal diameter). To be as realistic aspossible, the mannequin’s airway was pressurized using a mechanicalventilator. Extubation was defined as an abrupt loss of airway pressure(Fig. 1). ETT traction was performed till extubation by a tensile testingmachine. The force required to achieve extubation was recorded. Fivemeasurements per condition were collected. Results are presented asmedian and interquartile range [IQR]. Comparisons were performedwith Wilcoxon test or Kruskal–Wallis test and Bonferroni post hoc analysis.A p-value < 0.05 was considered significant.Results: In June 2023, 140 tests were completed.Whatever the device, the force yielding extubation was lower whenthe traction was applied in the sagittal than in the frontal plan: 44 [26–57] and 108 [88–145] N (p < 0.001), respectively (pooled data). The tractionspeed had no significant influence: 65 [43–101] and 87 [35–117] N(p = 0.4) at 5 and 50 cm/min traction speed, respectively.In the sagittal plan, unlike what was observed with other securing systems,the force yielding extubation was not different between bothshort and long adhesive elastic bands and the absence of securing systems.Forces yielding extubation with respect to the securing systemsand the traction plan are detailed in Fig. 2.Conclusions: Extubation is more easily observed when the ETT waspulled in the sagittal rather than the frontal plan and when it wassecured with adhesive elastic bands. Other securing systems performedgrossly similarly.