Role of Metal Cocatalysts in the Photocatalytic Production of Hydrogen from Water Revisited

The use of photocatalysts to promote the production of molecular hydrogen from water, following the so-called water splitting reaction, continues to be a promising route for the green production of fuels. The molecular basis of this photocatalysis is the photoexcitation of electrons from the valence band of semiconductors to their conduction band, from which they can be transferred to chemical reactants, protons in the case of water, to promote a reduction reaction. The mechanism by which such a process takes place has been studied extensively using titanium oxide, a simple material that fulfills most requirements for water splitting. However, photocatalysis with TiO₂ tends to be highly inefficient; a cocatalyst, commonly a late transition metal (Au, Pt) in nanoparticle form, needs to be added to facilitate the production of H₂. The metal is widely believed to help with the scavenging of the excited electrons from the conduction band of the semiconductor in order to prevent their recombination with the accompanying hole formed in the valence band, a step that cancels the initial photon absorption and competes with the photolytic chemical reduction. Here we review and analyze the molecular basis for that mechanism and argue for an alternative explanation, that the role of the metal is to help with the recombination of the atomic hydrogen atoms produced by proton reduction on the semiconductor surface instead. First, we summarize what is known about the electronic structure of these photocatalysts and how the electronic levels need to line up for the reduction of protons in water to be feasible. Next, we review the current understanding of the dynamics of the steps associated with the absorption of photons, the de-excitation via electron-hole pair recombination and fluorescence decay, and the electronic transitions that lead to proton reduction, and contrast those with the rates of the chemical steps required to produce molecular hydrogen. The following section addresses the changes introduced by the addition of the metal cocatalyst, comparatively evaluating its role as either an electron scavenger or a promoter of the recombination of hydrogen atoms. A discussion of the viable chemical mechanisms for the latter pathway is included. Finally, we briefly mention other associated aspects of this photocatalysis, including the possible promotion of H₂ production with visible light via resonant excitation of the surface plasmon of Au nanoparticles, the use of single-metal (Au, Pt) atom catalysts and of yolk-shell nanostructures, and the reduction of organic molecules. We end with a brief personal perspective on the possible generality of the concepts introduced in this Critical Review.