Impact of the Unstirred Water Layer on the Permeation of Small-Molecule Drugs

Over the last two decades, numerous molecular dynamics (MD) simulation-based investigations have attempted to predict the membrane permeability to small-molecule drugs as indicators of their bioavailability, a majority of which utilize the inhomogeneous solubility diffusion (ISD) model. However, MD-based membrane permeability is routinely 3–4 orders of magnitude larger than the values measured with the intestinal perfusion technique. There have been contentious discussions on the sources of the large discrepancies, and the two indisputable, potentially dominant ones are the fixed protonation state of the permeant and the neglect of the unstirred water layer (UWL). Employing six small-molecule drugs of different biopharmaceutical classification system classes, the current MD study relies on the ISD model but introduces the (de)protonation of the permeant by characterizing the permeation free energy of both neutral and charged states. In addition, the role of the UWL as a potential resistance against permeation is explored. The new MD protocol closely mimics the nature of small-molecule permeation and yields estimates that agree well with in vivo intestinal permeability.