医学
肺栓塞
急诊医学
儿科
重症监护医学
内科学
作者
Adhrith Vutukuri,Quang Ngoc La
摘要
To the editor: We enjoyed reading the article by Jossein et al., titled "Failure rate of the pulmonary embolism rule-out criteria rule for adults 35 years or younger: Findings from the RIETE Registry" and would like to offer additional commentary on the methodology and clinical implications of this research.1 We hope these perspectives may provide insight into areas that may require further research and improvement. Jossein et al. reported validity of the PERC-35 rule, highlighting its potential to reduce imaging and radiation exposure in young patients. They found that the PERC-35 rule demonstrated a low false-negative rate of 0.35%, suggesting the test's trustability in this age group. The paper calls for further research validation of the PERC-35 rule via a prospective study and concluded that in the future, the PERC-35 rule could be a valuable tool in an emergency department setting. Firstly, the study's reliance on the RIETE Registry provides a large data set, but its retrospective nature introduces biases and limitations. For example, the absence of formal documentation for pretest PE probability undermines the appropriate application of the PERC-35 rule, which is designed for patients with low pretest probability.1, 2 This gap challenges the validity of the conclusions. Next, we noted that the study excluded pregnancy and postpartum conditions, despite these being significant risk factors for PE in young women. Nearly half of the female PERC-35N patients in the study were pregnant or postpartum. The addition of a "pregnancy or postpartum" criterion could enhance the rule's relevance and prevent unnecessary imaging in this demographic. Although a practice of being unnecessarily thorough with guidelines and criteria can lead to longer experimental periods and increased costs,3 it is still essential to include further detail in the PERC-35 rule to make it applicable and accurate for a wider demographic. Finally, the validation of the PERC-35 rule for pulmonary embolism in younger persons is examined in this work in a timely and pertinent manner. The study suggests more prospective research for better clinical use and emphasizes how the rule may prevent needless imaging and radiation exposure. We commend the authors for pointing out areas where the PERC-35 regulation might be improved for wider applicability in addition to stressing the significance of evidence-based decision making in emergency situations. We anticipate reading about upcoming research that sheds more light on these variables. The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no new data were created or analyzed in this study.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI