In this paper, we examine the influence of past experience on firm search behavior. According to the Behavioral Theory of the Firm, search tends to be not only motivated by a rather specific problem, but also to be simple-minded and local. Consistent with prior literature, we propose that investments in R&D will be strongly driven by problemsitic search. However, we contend that this tendency will be heavily influenced by the firm’s previous investment history because a firm with little prior experience investing in R&D will be unlikely to turn to R&D search when they experience performance shortfalls. Furthermore, we argue that the path dependence of problemistic search will be strongest for large firms. Finally, building on these arguments, we examine the extent to which past experience will influence a firm’s tendency to engage in market search in response to performance shortfalls.