Abstract Although perovskite solar cells (PSCs) are widely recognized for their partial self-healing behaviour, the fundamental mechanisms linking degradation and recovery remain poorly understood, particularly the role of mobile ions. By directly comparing a stable and a poorly stable system, we demonstrate in this work that characterization at the fresh stage alone is inadequate to predict long-term stability or ionic behaviour. Instead, light/dark cycling emerges as a reliable indicator, unveiling the cumulative nature of ion-driven degradation, which ultimately dictates the extent and reversibility of performance losses. Intriguingly, devices that appear to exhibit minimal ionic effects in their fresh state can evolve into highly unstable systems under operation, while others with stronger initial ionic signatures may demonstrate greater operational stability. Furthermore, we identify temperature and dark resting time as important control parameters for regulating ion migration and recovery. Together, these findings highlight test protocols based on light/dark cycling as a transformative approach for understanding and controlling degradation, offering new pathways toward extending the lifetime of PSCs.