Climate obligations of states: the 2025 advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice
作者
Alexander Mikhailovich Solntsev
出处
期刊:Международное правосудие [Institute for Law and Public Policy] 日期:2025-01-01卷期号:15 (4): 3-25被引量:1
标识
DOI:10.21128/2226-2059-2025-4-3-25
摘要
This article presents a comprehensive scholarly and legal analysis of the International Court of Justice’s advisory opinion, which defines the international legal obligations of states in connection with climate change. The author identifies the content, structure, and legal nature of states’ climate obligations, as well as the significance of the advisory opinion for the development of international law. Based on an analysis of the advisory opinion’s text, the author demonstrates that the Court, for the first time, systematically interpreted three key international treaties—the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, the Kyoto Protocol, and the Paris Agreement—emphasizing their complementarity and the absence of legal contradictions between them. The article pays particular attention to states’ obligations to prepare nationally determined contributions (NDCs) in accordance with the Paris Agreement. The Court recognized this as a legally binding act, noting that this obligation includes elements of both a commitment of result and conduct, implemented in compliance with a high standard of due diligence and the principle of “the highest possible ambition”. The author explores the relationship between climate change obligations and customary international law, highlighting such customs as the duty to prevent significant transboundary environmental harm and the duty to cooperate. The article devotes particular attention to the analysis of climate change obligations arising from the treaties of such areas of international law as international human rights law and the international law of the sea. The article also analyzes issues of international state responsibility, including the recognition of obligations to combat climate change as obligations erga omnes and the possibility of compensation for breach of obligations. Ultimately, the author concludes that the 2025 advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice forms the conceptual and normative basis for the further development of the global regime of international legal protection of climate change.