Although qualitative methods are particularly suited to research and evaluation in education there are few agreed guidelines for the analysis of qualitative data. Qualitative researchers are also often delinquent in reporting on their analytic procedures. In this paper we attempt to initiate a debate on the analysis of qualitative data by outlining some basic principles for data analysis based on sociological fieldwork methods; by reviewing the contemporary American literature on qualitative data analysis; and by providing three examples of how we analysed qualitative data in different research and evaluation settings. We conclude by arguing for the establishing of a tradition of eclecticism within qualitative methodology.