作者
Zhou Qin,Yuhong Xue,Tianxing Wang,Yucheng Zou,Ziqing Hou,Youmin Zhang,Xinai Zhang,Yongqiang Shi,Xiaodong Zhai,Quancai Sun,Ye Peng,Zhikun Yang,Xiaowei Huang,Povey Megan,Xiaobo Zou,Zhi-Hua Li
摘要
Three-dimensional (3D) and four-dimensional (4D) food printing technologies have evolved from shape-making demonstrations to digitally controlled food production. However, comparative literature remains challenging due to incomplete reporting on material preparation, rheological experimental protocols, printer configurations, and product quality measurements. Furthermore, food-related findings are often discussed alongside non-food engineering concepts, lacking a clear distinction in the weight of evidence. This review analyzes the entire production chain, from material preparation and rheological characterization to printer operation, printed product quality, and application deployment. At each stage, we examine whether reported results are supported by adequate testing conditions, controls, variability estimates, and food-related evidence. Reported rheological ranges cannot define a universal printability window, as their meaning depends on measurement and printing conditions. A printed food can only be classified as 4D food if its response is intentionally programmed during printing, activated by specific stimuli, measured over time, and repeated across different samples. Evidence regarding sensory acceptability, clinical application, hygiene, shelf life, yield, and resource utilization is far less mature than evidence regarding geometric feasibility. In summary, existing literature supports conditional material-process relationships rather than validated universal models. Integrating the information needed to interpret and reproduce these relationships by domain of evidence allows for the differentiation of findings from food validation studies from specific system observations and engineering assumptions that still require testing in edible systems.