基础(证据)
生物多样性
生物
环境伦理学
环境资源管理
环境规划
生态学
概念框架
工程伦理学
全球生物多样性
分类学(生物学)
生物多样性保护
作者
ANDREW A. DAVINACK,Rylie A Seaberg
标识
DOI:10.1080/14772000.2026.2684293
摘要
Environmental DNA (eDNA) has expanded rapidly from proof-of-concept demonstrations to a widely used tool in biodiversity assessment, invasive species surveillance, fisheries management and conservation monitoring. This growth has been accompanied by numerous studies comparing the performance of eDNA against traditional survey techniques such as nets, electrofishing, traps and visual observations. These comparisons frequently conclude that eDNA is more sensitive or detects more taxa, often assuming that eDNA detections correspond to the same ecological or taxonomic entities observed by conventional methods. We argue that many perceived mismatches between eDNA and organism-based surveys can arise from a conceptual gap: eDNA detects molecular traces, not organisms. These traces are shaped by biological shedding, physical transport and degradation, as well as analytical processing during sampling, PCR, sequencing and taxonomic assignment. Consequently, eDNA and traditional surveys measure fundamentally different kinds of entities. We synthesize key insights across the eDNA literature and introduce a simplified “inference chain” that illustrates how biological, physical, and analytical filters transform DNA shed into the environment into a taxonomic detection. This framework clarifies why eDNA observations are inherently indirect, spatially and temporally integrated, and dependent on local environmental conditions and methodological decisions. Divergent species lists are therefore not anomalies but predictable outcomes of different measurement systems. Whereas traditional surveys reflect direct encounters with organisms, eDNA detections represent ecological inferences reconstructed from transformed material. Recognizing eDNA as an inferential tool provides a clearer foundation for biodiversity surveys, method comparison and communication with other stakeholders. Explicitly acknowledging the inference chain will enhance interpretation and support the continued maturation of eDNA within systematics and biodiversity science. We emphasize that eDNA and traditional surveys provide complementary perspectives on biodiversity but require distinct interpretive frameworks.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI