心理学
情境伦理学
考试(生物学)
认知
认知心理学
社会心理学
测试有效性
应用心理学
心理测量学
认知测验
发展心理学
预测效度
心理测试
增量有效性
验证试验
认知偏差
结构效度
社会认知
临床判断
作者
Filip Lievens,You Zhou,Jomel Wei Xuan Ng,Liyan Xi,Yixin Tian,Paul R. Sackett,Michelle P. Martín‐Raugh
摘要
Traditionally, situational judgment tests (SJTs) include text-based situations and ask candidates to pick the best and worst response option.Over the years, various new SJT paradigms have been developed to increase validity, reduce incidental cognitive load, and/or lower costs.Examples are multimedia SJTs, constructed response SJTs, and single-response SJTs.First, this study investigates how the traditional SJT paradigm performs in terms of criterion-related validity by updating prior meta-analyses.Second, this study provides initial, meta-analytic evidence on the criterion-related validity and cognitive load of several new SJT paradigms.On the basis of 457 independent samples from 302 studies (total N = 244,257), results showed that SJTs were not only predictive of job performance but also of academic performance, organizational citizenship behavior, and counterproductive work behavior.SJT validity was higher in operational (i.e., applicant) settings than in nonoperational settings and could also be expanded to new content (e.g., emotion and cross-cultural management).In terms of comparing traditional and new SJT paradigms, multimedia SJTs had validity equal to text-based ones but lower cognitive load.Importantly, the multiple-choice modality did not significantly outperform written constructed response modalities in terms of validity, and the cognitive loading of webcamconstructed responses was even lower than that of other response modalities.The implications of these findings are among others discussed in the context of the cost effectiveness of SJTs vis-à-vis other selection procedures.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI