医学
康复
可比性
成对比较
重症监护医学
物理疗法
变时性
队列
限制
梅德林
心力衰竭
队列研究
回顾性队列研究
心率
物理医学与康复
临床试验
心脏病学
报销
运动不耐症
荟萃分析
循证医学
试验预测值
鉴定(生物学)
内科学
逻辑回归
系统回顾
作者
Margot Vermeiren,Nore Primus,Kato Heyns,Véronique Cornelissen,Rik Willems,Tim Van Puyvelde,Joris Ector,Kaatje Goetschalckx,Peter Sinnaeve
标识
DOI:10.1093/eurjpc/zwag253
摘要
AIMS: Chronotropic incompetence (CI), defined as the inability of the heart to appropriately increase its rate in response to exercise, is associated with exercise intolerance and adverse events. However, the diagnostic criteria for CI vary widely, limiting their clinical applicability and comparability across studies. Here we aim to systematically map the current definitions of CI and the prediction models used to estimate age-predicted maximal heart rate (APMHR). We illustrate how this diagnostic variability affects the identification of CI in patients enrolled in a cardiac rehabilitation program. METHODS: A scoping review systematically identified all published definitions of CI and prediction models for APMHR. A retrospective study evaluated the agreement between definitions in patients participating in cardiac rehabilitation. RESULTS: A total of 86 studies were included. Seventeen distinct methods to define CI were identified, ranging from absolute or relative peak heart rate parameters to approaches incorporating workload. In many cases, the applied cut-off values lacked a rationale. In parallel, numerous APMHR formulas were identified, differing by sex, age category, fitness level, clinical status, and the use of beta-blocker therapy, showing limited accuracy. In the clinical setting agreement between four major definitions was poor and pairwise comparisons between them showed significant differences in classification. CONCLUSION: Current methods to define CI and predict APMHR are inconsistent and problematic. This review provides a practical framework for selecting a context-appropriate definition and formula. It identifies current methodological gaps and highlights the need for future research to establish a consensus definition of CI.
科研通智能强力驱动
Strongly Powered by AbleSci AI