Little is known about the functioning of informal leadership in teams whose formal leaders engage in laissez-faire behavior by shirking their leadership responsibilities. Drawing on social learning theory, we propose that team members interpret laissez-faire formal leadership as a signal that leadership is unnecessary or inappropriate, causing them to reduce their informal leadership contributions. We further argue that the negative association between laissez-faire formal leadership and informal leadership behavior is weaker for team members who are inherently highly motivated to lead. We also consider the implications for team task performance and viability. In a recall-based experiment of 131 working individuals and a multi-source field study of 141 teams, we consistently find that laissez-faire formal leadership is negatively associated with informal leadership behavior, but not for team members who are highly motivated to lead. In the second study, we also find that the negative indirect associations between laissez-faire formal leadership and team task performance and viability via team members’ informal leadership behavior are weaker for more highly motivated team members.