ESG rating divergence: A systematic literature review of drivers, implications and regulatory challenges
作者
Πιριτζαους Πολυχρονια,Piritzaous Polychronia
标识
DOI:10.26233/heallink.tuc.105653
摘要
ESG ratings have gained more importance in recent years as tools of information in sustainable finance. However, an individual firm could be awarded significantly different ESG ratings by different rating agencies, resulting in ambiguity about the concept of ESG ratings. In this thesis, the phenomenon of ESG rating divergence is examined via a literature review. Specifically, three research questions will be addressed: what are the factors that cause ESG rating divergence,how does divergence affect investors and financial markets, and whether regulation and standardization efforts are useful in increasing transparency and comparability. It becomes evident from the results that divergence in ESG ratings cannot be dismissed as mere randomness but instead should be interpreted as an organized result of differences in the scope of ESG matters, methods, metrics, data sources, treatment of gaps and controversies, and scoring rules. The literature review provides examples of the impact of divergence on various practical areas, including portfolio building, screening, pricing, stewardship, and empirical research designs. It is important to note that efforts at improving transparency and governance, such as those undertaken by the IOSCO recommendations and the EU ESG Rating Regulation, will probably not lead to total convergence, as it may result from methodological pluralism. Overall, the thesis argues that divergence in ESG ratings should be addressed via the enhancement of transparency, robustness checks, and governance practices rather than dismissed as a measurement problem.