Empirical force-field andab initio calculations on delocalized open chain cations

Force-field calculations are reported for large delocalized cations. The results for the geometries, heats of formation, and π-electron densities agree well with MP2(full)/6–31G* ab initio calculations. Both methods give similar results for the distortion of the carbon skeletons of unsubstituted cations by hyperconjugating methyl groups. Because of the SCF treatment of π-interactions, the MMP2 force-field technique enables calculations of resonance energies in delocalized cations. The additional resonance stabilization produced by extending conjugation is directly related to the π-charge on the carbon at which a vinyl group is substituted. The good agreement of MMP2 results for nonbonded resonance effects in large delocalized cationic π-systems with ab initio data suggests that MMP2 can be used to study the influence of these interactions in cationic π-systems too large to be calculated by correlated ab initio methods. © 1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.