Performance evaluation of enzymatic total bile acid (TBA) routine assays: systematic comparison of five fifth-generation TBA cycling methods and their individual bile acid recovery from HPLC-MS/MS reference

Abstract Objectives Serum total bile acid (TBA) levels are frequently assessed in clinical routine for the early detection of hepatobiliary dysfunction. However, the comparability of current 5th-generation TBA cycle assays based on 3α-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase (3α-HSD) and their ability to quantify individual bile acids has not been systematically addressed. Methods Patient serum samples (n=60) across the diagnostically relevant TBA range (1–200 μmol/L) were analyzed using five TBA routine assays from Abbott, DiaSys, Diazyme, Beijing Strong (BSBE) and Randox on the same analyzer (BioMajesty ® JCA-BM6010/C). The assays were compared using Passing-Bablok regression and the recovery of 11 individual BAs was evaluated against RP-HPLC-MS/MS as non-enzymatic reference method. Results Despite excellent correlation (Spearman r ≥0.99), the assays showed proportional differences (slope) ranging from 0.99 (BSBE/Randox) to 1.24 (Abbott/DiaSys). The assays showed considerable deviation in the recovery of competitor’s calibrators and controls, and large heterogeneity in the recovery of individual BAs, with mean deviations from reference value between 13 % (DiaSys) and 42 % (Abbott). CA and TCA were measured most accurately and consistently, whereas GCA, CDCA, DCA, UDCA, and conjugates were over- or undermeasured to varying degrees. Conclusions The linear relationship and constant proportional bias between all five routine assays enable the harmonization of TBA measurements up to 60 μmol/L. However, for patient samples with high TBA levels and disease-specific overrepresentation of individual BAs, harmonization will require: i) optimized reaction conditions to equalize substrate specificity, and ii) calibration to a common, commutable reference material with well-defined BA composition instead of internal standards spiked with different BAs.