A response to ‘Acupuncture compared to placebo‐acupuncture for postoperative nausea and vomiting prophylaxis: A randomised placebo‐controlled patient and observer blind trial’, Streitberger K, Diefenbacher M, Bauer A et al . Anaesthesia 2004; 59: 142–9
I read with interest this acupuncture study on postoperative nausea and vomiting (PONV). Although the use of acupuncture for PONV is backed up by systematic reviews [1,2], acupuncture was not more effective than placebo acupuncture in this high-quality study. Regarding their non-significant results, firstly, a question arises whether PC6 has a specific anti-emetic effect. Research into the anti-emetic effect of PC6 stimulation was initiated by Prof Dundee who witnessed such practice in Chinese antenatal clinics. Since then, this intervention has been trialed in nausea and vomiting of any aetiology. However, the single acupuncture point PC6 stimulation may not be sufficient in reducing the incidence of PONV. A combination of other points, e.g. ST36, ST40, CV12, could better reflect everyday practice and recently studies adopted such approaches [3,4]. Second, recent trials with positive results in this area had a longer stimulation duration and the needles were maintained postoperatively [3,5]. This implies that duration of acupuncture stimulation may be as important as the initiation time or patient's consciousness [2]. The effect of acupuncture can vary with the technique used, e.g. duration of needling, depth of needling, type of stimulation. In addition to testing the acupuncture effect on PONV, future trials seeking optimal conditions of acupuncture intervention are also required.