Biomechanical Effects of a Horizontal Medial Meniscal Tear and Subsequent Leaflet Resection

BACKGROUND: Horizontal, degenerative tears of the medial meniscus and subsequent meniscectomy can compromise the biomechanical function of the meniscus in load transmission and weightbearing, leading to the development of radiographic and symptomatic tibiofemoral arthritis. HYPOTHESIS: Resection of both leaflets of a horizontal medial meniscal tear will increase peak contact pressures and decrease contact areas in comparison with resection of only the inferior leaflet. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Twelve fresh-frozen human cadaveric knees had tibiofemoral peak contact pressures and contact areas under an 1800-N axial load measured by Tekscan in the control state. A horizontal tear was created in the posterior horn of the medial meniscus, and the knees were retested. The knees were tested a third time after resection of the inferior leaflet (single leaflet) and a final time after resection of the superior leaflet (both leaflets). The Friedman test was used to test for group differences in peak pressure (psi) and contact area (mm(2)) between test conditions (native, tear, inferior leaflet resection, and resection of both leaflets). RESULTS: For the medial compartment, there was a statistically significant difference in peak pressure (P = .03) but not in contact area (P = .70) between testing conditions. Median peak pressure in the medial compartment was significantly greater for resection of both leaflets compared with the tear (406.5 vs 294.7 psi, respectively; P = .002). Median contact area in the medial compartment was greatest for resection of both leaflets (602.7 mm(2)), but there were no statistically significant differences between test conditions (P = .70). For the lateral compartment, there were no statistically significant differences in peak pressure (P = .99) or contact area (P = .77) between test conditions. CONCLUSION: Resection of a single inferior leaflet after a horizontal medial meniscal tear preserves much of the original biomechanical function of the meniscus. Resection of both leaflets leads to a significant increase in contact pressure dispersed over the same contact area, which results in an undesirable biomechanical environment. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Arthroscopic inferior leaflet resection is a viable option for providing symptomatic relief of horizontal medial meniscal tears and preserves the ability of the meniscus to absorb axial loading on the knee joint, theoretically decreasing the risk of subsequent osteoarthritis.